Discussion
Centering Palestinian women's lived experiences through reproductive justice [ 8 ] and intersectional lenses [ 23 ], this phenomenological study provides crucial insights into how Palestinian women navigate reproductive healthcare under Israeli military occupation in the West Bank. Our findings explicitly name Israel as the occupying power responsible for the structural barriers described and situate these barriers within the broader context of settler colonial occupation. The findings reveal a complex landscape where political restrictions, cultural norms, and healthcare fragmentation co-constitute unique challenges for women's health access and outcomes. Our analysis demonstrates how military administrative control over healthcare systematically compromises reproductive vulnerability, systematically eroding autonomy while generating innovative resistance.
This study advances feminist political ecology by demonstrating how territorial control operates through the regulation of bodies, particularly women's reproductive bodies. Our findings reveal how checkpoint systems and permit regimes imposed by Israeli military authorities function as biopower mechanisms that control not only movement through space but also reproductive temporality, when women can seek care, give birth, and make reproductive choices. This body-territory nexus represents a distinct form of gendered spatial control that extends traditional understandings of military occupation.
The four major themes show how macro-level political structures violently reconfigure micro-level healthcare experiences, affecting not only health outcomes but also women's agency, dignity, and reproductive autonomy. These findings extend beyond general conflict health impacts to reveal distinctly gendered experiences of administrative control over healthcare access and administrative obstacles with profound health consequences.
The political precision of our analysis is essential: the permit system is not an abstract bureaucratic barrier, but a system imposed and administered by the Israeli military. Checkpoints are not neutral security measures but mechanisms of control that systematically obstruct healthcare access. The fragmentation of the healthcare system is not incidental but reflects the broader political fragmentation of Palestinian territory through Israeli policies of separation and control. Throughout this discussion, we explicitly link the barriers described by participants to the actors and systems that produce them.
Although the structural barriers identified in this study were experienced across all participant groups, their manifestations varied according to women's geographic location, socioeconomic circumstances, and social position. Participants from Hebron, particularly those living near Israeli settlements, more frequently described prolonged checkpoint delays, permit-related obstacles, and heightened mobility restrictions than participants from Ramallah, reflecting differences in the intensity of military control across the West Bank. Women from lower-income households emphasized the compounded financial burden of transportation, overnight accommodation, and repeated healthcare visits, while rural participants described fewer available healthcare facilities and greater dependence on referral systems than those residing in more urban areas. These findings illustrate that reproductive healthcare access under occupation is not experienced uniformly but is shaped by the intersection of gender with geography, socioeconomic status, and local political conditions. Such variation reinforces the value of reproductive justice as an analytical framework by demonstrating how occupation-related policies interact with existing social inequalities to produce differentiated experiences of reproductive healthcare access.
The systematic nature of checkpoint delays, permit requirements, and healthcare fragmentation creates particular challenges for reproductive healthcare, which operates within biological timeframes that cannot be negotiated without significant risks. The checkpoint-permit regime imposed by Israeli military authorities constitutes gendered temporal violence where pregnancy's urgency collides with deliberate administrative delays [ 16 ]. Unlike other conflict contexts, Palestine's institutionalized permit system, administered by Israeli military authorities, transfers clinical decisions to military authorities, actors with no medical training, violating principles of medical ethics and international law [ 28 ]. This system exploits biological timeframes through military control over reproductive temporality, the exertion of medical veto power via permit denials, and structural fragmentation that disrupts continuity of care [ 14 ].
Checkpoint delays and permit denials represent a form of structural violence, a systematic harm embedded in political structures that prevents individuals from meeting their basic needs. The military occupation creates conditions where women cannot access essential healthcare not because of natural disasters or resource limitations, but because of deliberate policies designed to control Palestinian movement and life. This may constitute a violation of the right to health as guaranteed by international law, including the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (Article 12) and the Fourth Geneva Convention (Article 56) [ 9 ].
The impact on health outcomes demonstrates how political restrictions systematically compromise reproductive justice principles: the right to have children, not have children, and parent safely [ 8 ]. Emergency complications like checkpoint births represent violations of Geneva Convention IV (Article 56), while restricted family planning constitutes state-mediated reproductive coercion [ 9 ]. Our findings demonstrate how Israeli occupation policies systematically violate all three pillars of reproductive justice:
First, the right to have children is compromised through restricted access to prenatal and obstetric care. Women described missed prenatal appointments, delayed emergency care, and fears of giving birth at checkpoints, all of which threaten the health of mothers and infants. Second, the right not to have children is limited by barriers to family planning services. Women described inability to access contraception, difficulty obtaining regular check-ups for contraceptive monitoring, and pressure to have children closer together than desired due to healthcare access barriers. Third, the right to parent safely is undermined by the broader conditions of territorial control, dispossession, and systemic insecurity. Women described how the occupation creates conditions where they cannot parent safely, where fear of checkpoints, permit denials, and healthcare fragmentation create constant anxiety about their children's health and safety.
First, the right to have children is compromised through restricted access to prenatal and obstetric care. Women described missed prenatal appointments, delayed emergency care, and fears of giving birth at checkpoints, all of which threaten the health of mothers and infants.
Second, the right not to have children is limited by barriers to family planning services. Women described inability to access contraception, difficulty obtaining regular check-ups for contraceptive monitoring, and pressure to have children closer together than desired due to healthcare access barriers.
Third, the right to parent safely is undermined by the broader conditions of territorial control, dispossession, and systemic insecurity. Women described how the occupation creates conditions where they cannot parent safely, where fear of checkpoints, permit denials, and healthcare fragmentation create constant anxiety about their children's health and safety.
Participant narratives described profound feelings of helplessness when permit delays and checkpoint restrictions prevented timely access to care, illustrating how political barriers often took precedence over urgent medical needs and contributed to adverse maternal health outcomes [ 9 , 15 , 16 ].
Traditional gender roles become amplified through bureaucratic integration, where military restrictions legitimize patriarchal control. This creates a form of "amplified patriarchy" where political and cultural forms of control reinforce each other. The requirement for male guardians intersects with permit systems to create a form of double confinement, where cultural norms and military checkpoints collectively restrict women's movement; permit-dependent autonomy, in which male authority is reinforced through bureaucratic control over access; and forced localism, trapping women within stigmatizing and often inadequate local healthcare services.
Participants described how checkpoint-related barriers reinforced existing patriarchal family dynamics, with travel difficulties sometimes being used within families to discourage routine reproductive healthcare, illustrating the intersection of political restrictions and gender norms [ 3 , 8 , 19 ].
Women's remarkable resilience represents adaptive responses to systemic barriers rather than substitutes for institutional responsibility. Although women demonstrated considerable agency and creativity in navigating healthcare challenges, these coping strategies should not be romanticized or interpreted as solutions to structural inequities. Instead, resilience reflects survival under conditions of structural violence rather than a resolution of those conditions. Community support networks functioned as informal healthcare infrastructures, facilitating the sharing of health information, coordinating transportation to healthcare facilities, and promoting collective knowledge to mitigate the effects of healthcare fragmentation and restricted access [ 8 , 20 ].
Documentation of checkpoint delays represents a form of everyday resistance that transforms lived experiences into evidence for advocacy and accountability [ 18 ]. These acts of resistance are not merely individual coping strategies but collective political actions that challenge the occupation's control over healthcare access.
However, it is essential to recognize that resilience is not evenly distributed. Women with greater resources (education, income, and family support) have more capacity to navigate healthcare barriers. Women from lower-income households, rural areas, and with less education face compounded vulnerabilities. Our findings reveal these intersectional differences, showing how class, geography, and education shape women's ability to access care. This highlights the need for interventions that address not only political barriers but also socioeconomic inequalities that amplify their impact.
Based on participants' accounts and consistent with international human rights frameworks, the following measures merit urgent policy consideration:
Priority pregnancy permits: To reduce arbitrary delays and denials, relevant authorities could consider implementing automatic six-month travel authorizations for pregnant women upon prenatal confirmation, thereby reducing administrative burdens and improving continuity of care. Obstetric emergency corridors: International humanitarian bodies and local health authorities might explore establishing midwife-staffed emergency stations at major checkpoints, aligned with WHO emergency maternal care frameworks, to provide immediate care when delays occur. Unified health records: Supporting the development of a coordinated e-health record system across fragmented providers could address the systemic gaps in care continuity, allowing medical histories to follow women regardless of which facility they can access.
Priority pregnancy permits: To reduce arbitrary delays and denials, relevant authorities could consider implementing automatic six-month travel authorizations for pregnant women upon prenatal confirmation, thereby reducing administrative burdens and improving continuity of care.
Obstetric emergency corridors: International humanitarian bodies and local health authorities might explore establishing midwife-staffed emergency stations at major checkpoints, aligned with WHO emergency maternal care frameworks, to provide immediate care when delays occur.
Unified health records: Supporting the development of a coordinated e-health record system across fragmented providers could address the systemic gaps in care continuity, allowing medical histories to follow women regardless of which facility they can access.
Our findings support consideration of broader accountability and monitoring mechanisms that may help protect Palestinian women's access to reproductive healthcare under conditions of military occupation. Informed by participants' experiences and existing international legal frameworks, international organizations and relevant stakeholders may consider the following measures:
Recognition of checkpoint-related maternal deaths and delays within international humanitarian law frameworks: International bodies may consider whether deaths and serious harm resulting from obstruction of emergency medical access warrant enhanced monitoring and accountability under the Fourth Geneva Convention. Further examination of the systematic denial of healthcare access: Relevant international legal and human rights institutions may consider whether patterns of healthcare access restrictions require further investigation under applicable international legal frameworks. Strengthening independent monitoring of healthcare access: International organizations, including the World Health Organization, may consider expanding independent, real-time monitoring systems to document permit delays, checkpoint-related barriers, and disruptions to maternal and reproductive healthcare services in order to support evidence-based policy development and humanitarian responses.
Recognition of checkpoint-related maternal deaths and delays within international humanitarian law frameworks: International bodies may consider whether deaths and serious harm resulting from obstruction of emergency medical access warrant enhanced monitoring and accountability under the Fourth Geneva Convention.
Further examination of the systematic denial of healthcare access: Relevant international legal and human rights institutions may consider whether patterns of healthcare access restrictions require further investigation under applicable international legal frameworks.
Strengthening independent monitoring of healthcare access: International organizations, including the World Health Organization, may consider expanding independent, real-time monitoring systems to document permit delays, checkpoint-related barriers, and disruptions to maternal and reproductive healthcare services in order to support evidence-based policy development and humanitarian responses.
hese policy implications are informed by participants' accounts and existing international legal frameworks, including the Fourth Geneva Convention's obligation for occupying powers to ensure medical care for protected persons [ 9 ] and the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights' guarantee of the right to health. Rather than representing conclusions derived solely from this qualitative study, they highlight potential directions for policy dialogue, international monitoring, and future research .
Methodology
This qualitative phenomenological study, informed by reproductive justice theory [ 8 ], feminist standpoint theory [ 22 ], and intersectionality [ 23 ], was designed to explore and understand the lived experiences of Palestinian women navigating reproductive and maternal healthcare access in the West Bank under Israeli military occupation. Reproductive justice theory served as the primary analytical lens, guiding our examination of how occupation policies systematically compromise women's ability to have children, not have children, and parent safely. The phenomenological approach was selected because it emphasizes understanding experiences from participants' own perspectives, allowing for exploration of meanings and interpretations that women attach to their healthcare journeys. The study employed Husserl's descriptive phenomenological framework, focusing on the essence of the phenomenon as experienced by participants with explicit bracketing of researchers' preconceptions through reflexive journals.
As Palestinian researchers working within the context of ongoing occupation, we acknowledge that our personal and professional backgrounds, particularly our urban, educated privileges, shaped both data collection and interpretation processes. We recognize that our urban residence, university education, and professional healthcare backgrounds may have limited our understanding of rural women's experiences, particularly those from villages around Hebron without higher education. Our privileged positions within Palestinian society may have influenced how participants from different socioeconomic backgrounds responded to questions and shared personal experiences.
Crucially, as Palestinian researchers who ourselves navigate the same permit regimes, movement restrictions, and occupation-related barriers described by participants, we engaged in explicit reflection on how this shared structural location shaped the research process. Our lived experience of occupation facilitated rapport with participants, enabling trust-building and cultural competence in understanding local contexts and gender dynamics. However, this shared experience also required careful reflexive practice to avoid projecting our own experiences onto participants' narratives and to remain attuned to the diversity of women's experiences across different geographic, socioeconomic, and educational contexts.
We actively reflected on how our positions might limit understanding of rural women's experiences and how our academic positions may have influenced how women from different backgrounds responded to questions. To mitigate potential bias and enhance analytic credibility, we conducted monthly peer debriefing sessions with rural community health workers from each study area, maintained daily reflexivity journals documenting how our positionality might affect the research, and consistently prioritized participants' voices over our own interpretations during analysis. Additionally, we employed member checking with participants from diverse educational and geographic backgrounds to validate our interpretations. Our shared structural location as Palestinians under occupation generated both insight and analytical challenges: it provided deep contextual understanding and facilitated trust, but also required deliberate effort to bracket our own experiences and remain open to diverse participant perspectives.
The study included 18 Palestinian women aged 18–45 years living in purposively selected areas of the West Bank, chosen to represent distinct access challenges: Ramallah, a relatively accessible urban center; Hebron, a high-restriction area located near Israeli settlements; and Nablus, a mid-restriction zone characterized by a rural–urban mix. Data saturation was achieved at Interview 16, confirmed through systematic analysis showing no new codes emerging across three successive analytical cycles [ 24 ]. The final sample of 18 participants exceeded this threshold, ensuring comprehensive representation across all geographic and demographic categories (see Table 1 ). Table 1 Participant demographics Characteristic N % Age Groups 18–25 years 5 27.8 26–35 years 8 44.4 36–45 years 5 27.8 Location Ramallah area 6 33.3 Hebron area 6 33.3 Nablus area 6 33.3 Marital Status Married 14 77.8 Single 3 16.7 Divorced/Widowed 1 5.6 Number of Children 0 4 22.2 1–2 7 38.9 3–4 5 27.8 5 + 2 11.1 Education Level Secondary or less 6 33.3 University/College 12 66.7 Employment Status Employed 8 44.4 Unemployed/Homemaker 10 55.6 Household Monthly Income (NIS) 6,000 2 11.1
Participant demographics
We acknowledge the exclusion of Area C villages and Gaza due to security constraints and access limitations, which represents a significant gap in capturing the most severe restriction experiences.
Data collection employed semi-structured, in-depth interviews conducted between March and June 2025, using trauma-informed protocols adapted from the World Health Organization's 2013 guidelines for research in conflict settings [ 25 ]. These protocols included ensuring counselor availability for post-interview support, allowing participants to pause or withdraw at any time, and avoiding graphic retraumatization by using carefully considered phrasing throughout the interviews.
Interviews were conducted in Arabic by trained female researchers experienced in working with women on sensitive topics. Interview locations were chosen by participants to ensure comfort and privacy, including participants' homes, community centers, and quiet public spaces.
The interview guide explored participants' experiences with reproductive healthcare access, including their encounters with checkpoints, permit applications, healthcare facility navigation, family decision-making processes, and coping strategies. Questions included: "Can you describe your experiences traveling to healthcare appointments?"; "How have movement restrictions affected your ability to access reproductive healthcare?"; and "What strategies have you developed to navigate these barriers?".
Data analysis followed Braun and Clarke's 2006 thematic analysis approach using NVivo 14 software to maintain an auditable coding trail [ 26 ]. The process began with familiarization through multiple readings of interview transcripts. The coding process involved three researchers (I.A., H.A., and N.A.) who coded data independently for the first three interviews to establish intercoder reliability, achieving 87% agreement. Disagreements were resolved through consensus discussion with the fourth author (U.A.) serving as arbiter when needed. After establishing coding consistency, the remaining interviews were coded collaboratively, with weekly team meetings to review emerging codes and refine the coding framework. Initial codes were generated systematically across the entire dataset, identifying features relevant to the research questions. These codes were then organized into broader themes capturing patterns of meaning across participants' experiences. The iterative analysis process involved three rounds of coding: (1) initial open coding of all transcripts; (2) axial coding to group related codes into categories; and (3) selective coding to refine themes and ensure they accurately represented participants' experiences.
Data saturation was rigorously confirmed at Interview 16 when no new codes emerged across three successive analytical cycles [ 24 ], but analysis continued through all 18 interviews to ensure comprehensive representation. The final thematic structure was validated through member checking with a strategically selected subset of 5 participants representing all geographic areas and age groups.
Trustworthiness was ensured through four strategies grounded in Lincoln and Guba's 1985 framework [ 27 ]: prolonged engagement, with a three-month immersion in field contexts; methodological triangulation, integrating interview data, researcher observations, and field notes; negative case analysis, which involved actively seeking disconfirming experiences; and peer examination of coding frameworks by external qualitative researchers to enhance analytical rigor.
Member checking involved sharing preliminary findings with participants to confirm accuracy and relevance. Rich, thick descriptions were provided to enable readers to assess transferability. An audit trail documented all analytical decisions including codebook evolution, theme refinement processes, and reflexivity documentation.
The thematic analysis of interviews revealed four major themes that encapsulate Palestinian women's lived experiences navigating reproductive healthcare under occupation. These themes, supported by rich participant narratives, provide insight into the complex intersection of gender, politics, and healthcare access in the West Bank.
This theme encompasses the systematic obstacles women face when seeking reproductive and maternal healthcare, reflecting the broader political context of occupation and its impact on healthcare systems. These barriers represent a form of structural violence whereby political structures systematically harm populations through institutionalized restrictions that prevent access to essential services.
Women consistently described military checkpoint delays as time-sensitive barriers with gendered consequences, particularly for emergency obstetric care [ 16 ]. Checkpoints impose significant and often dangerous delays, exploiting the biological timeframes of pregnancy and childbirth to create life-threatening situations. "When I was pregnant with my second child, I went into labor at night. We had to wait at the checkpoint for two hours. I was scared I would give birth there. The soldiers didn't care that I was in pain." (Participant 8, age 28, Hebron)
"When I was pregnant with my second child, I went into labor at night. We had to wait at the checkpoint for two hours. I was scared I would give birth there. The soldiers didn't care that I was in pain." (Participant 8, age 28, Hebron)
These accounts reveal how checkpoint delays exploit biological timeframes of pregnancy, creating a form of "gendered temporal violence" where the urgency of reproductive healthcare collides with deliberate administrative obstacles. Such delays constitute direct violations of international humanitarian law provisions for unimpeded medical access [ 9 ]. "For my monthly check-ups, I have to leave very early because I never know how long the checkpoint will take. Sometimes I wait for hours, and by the time I arrive, the doctor has finished for the day." (Participant 12, age 31, Nablus)
"For my monthly check-ups, I have to leave very early because I never know how long the checkpoint will take. Sometimes I wait for hours, and by the time I arrive, the doctor has finished for the day." (Participant 12, age 31, Nablus)
Women from villages near Israeli settlements faced particularly severe restrictions, with some checkpoints closing unpredictably, forcing women to take longer, more expensive routes to reach healthcare facilities. These closures are not random but reflect the systematic fragmentation of Palestinian geography through Israeli military control.
While all participants reported checkpoint delays, the severity varied significantly by geography. Women from Hebron, particularly those residing near Israeli settlements, described near-daily delays of up to three hours, whereas women from Ramallah experienced intermittent delays primarily during military closures or holidays. Rural participants without access to private transportation reported spending up to double the travel time compared to urban participants, as they had to rely on shared taxis that waited to fill before crossing.
The permit system administered by Israeli military authorities created additional layers of complexity for women seeking specialized reproductive healthcare, particularly those requiring services in East Jerusalem hospitals. This system effectively transfers clinical decisions about medical necessity to military authorities with no medical training, violating fundamental principles of medical ethics and international law. "I needed surgery for endometriosis, but the specialist is in Jerusalem. It took three months to get the permit, and by then my condition had worsened. They treat us like we're asking for a favor, not seeking medical care." (Participant 15, age 34, Ramallah) "My permit was denied twice without explanation. I was high-risk pregnancy and needed monitoring at Makassed Hospital. I felt helpless, like my baby's health didn't matter to them." (Participant 6, age 26, Hebron)
"I needed surgery for endometriosis, but the specialist is in Jerusalem. It took three months to get the permit, and by then my condition had worsened. They treat us like we're asking for a favor, not seeking medical care." (Participant 15, age 34, Ramallah)
"My permit was denied twice without explanation. I was high-risk pregnancy and needed monitoring at Makassed Hospital. I felt helpless, like my baby's health didn't matter to them." (Participant 6, age 26, Hebron)
The arbitrary nature of permit denials, which often occur without explanation or appeal mechanisms, creates a system of healthcare access contingent on military discretion rather than medical necessity. This constitutes a systematic violation of the right to health under international law.
Fragmentation disproportionately impacted continuity-dependent care like prenatal monitoring, forcing women to become system navigators [ 14 ]. The fragmentation of the healthcare system is not incidental but reflects the broader political fragmentation of Palestinian territory through Israeli policies of separation and control. "I started my prenatal care at the government clinic, but they referred me to Augusta Victoria Hospital for high-risk management. Then I needed to go to a private doctor because the waiting list was too long. No one talks to each other about my case." (Participant 3, age 29, Nablus) "Different doctors give different advice. The UNRWA clinic says one thing, the private doctor says another. As a woman, you don't know who to trust or which advice to follow." (Participant 17, age 38, Ramallah)
"I started my prenatal care at the government clinic, but they referred me to Augusta Victoria Hospital for high-risk management. Then I needed to go to a private doctor because the waiting list was too long. No one talks to each other about my case." (Participant 3, age 29, Nablus)
"Different doctors give different advice. The UNRWA clinic says one thing, the private doctor says another. As a woman, you don't know who to trust or which advice to follow." (Participant 17, age 38, Ramallah)
This fragmentation is compounded by the geographic barriers created by checkpoints and permit requirements, making continuity of care nearly impossible for many women.
This theme captures how structural barriers translate into concrete effects on women's health outcomes, reproductive choices, and healthcare experiences. These outcomes illustrate how occupation policies undermine the core principles of reproductive justice.
Women described how access barriers led to delayed care, missed appointments, and compromised health outcomes for themselves and their children. These delays often have life-threatening consequences, particularly for obstetric emergencies. "I missed several prenatal appointments because of curfews and checkpoint closures. When I finally gave birth, my baby had complications that might have been prevented with proper monitoring." (Participant 4, age 32, Hebron) "I had bleeding during pregnancy but was afraid to go to the hospital because of the checkpoint. I waited until it got worse. The doctor said I could have lost the baby." (Participant 11, age 27, Nablus)
"I missed several prenatal appointments because of curfews and checkpoint closures. When I finally gave birth, my baby had complications that might have been prevented with proper monitoring." (Participant 4, age 32, Hebron)
"I had bleeding during pregnancy but was afraid to go to the hospital because of the checkpoint. I waited until it got worse. The doctor said I could have lost the baby." (Participant 11, age 27, Nablus)
These accounts reveal how the fear of checkpoints and potential delays can deter women from seeking urgent care, creating a situation where political barriers lead to preventable morbidity and mortality.
Access to contraception and family planning services was compromised by movement restrictions and permit denials, directly compromising reproductive autonomy [ 8 ]. This represents a violation of the reproductive justice principle of the right not to have children. "I wanted to space my pregnancies, but the family planning clinic is far, and my husband doesn't like me traveling alone to checkpoints. I ended up having children closer together than I wanted." (Participant 9, age 30, Hebron)
"I wanted to space my pregnancies, but the family planning clinic is far, and my husband doesn't like me traveling alone to checkpoints. I ended up having children closer together than I wanted." (Participant 9, age 30, Hebron)
Such narratives demonstrate how spatial barriers enable reproductive coercion, where desired pregnancy spacing becomes impossible due to political geography. This represents a form of state-mediated reproductive control where political structures effectively dictate women's reproductive choices. "Birth control pills are available, but getting regular check-ups and monitoring is difficult. I stopped using them because I couldn't see the doctor regularly." (Participant 14, age 25, Ramallah)
"Birth control pills are available, but getting regular check-ups and monitoring is difficult. I stopped using them because I couldn't see the doctor regularly." (Participant 14, age 25, Ramallah)
Women's accounts of emergency situations highlighted life-threatening consequences of access barriers, creating lasting trauma and fear. These experiences not only threaten immediate survival but also produce long-term psychological harm and deterrent effects on future healthcare-seeking behavior. "My neighbor gave birth at the checkpoint. The ambulance couldn't cross, and the soldiers wouldn't let her husband help. It was traumatic for all of us who witnessed it." (Participant 7, age 35, Nablus) "I always worry about emergencies. What if I need urgent care and can't get through? This fear affects how I make decisions about my health and pregnancies." (Participant 16, age 33, Hebron)
"My neighbor gave birth at the checkpoint. The ambulance couldn't cross, and the soldiers wouldn't let her husband help. It was traumatic for all of us who witnessed it." (Participant 7, age 35, Nablus)
"I always worry about emergencies. What if I need urgent care and can't get through? This fear affects how I make decisions about my health and pregnancies." (Participant 16, age 33, Hebron)
These emergency complications represent the most extreme manifestation of the health consequences of occupation policies and constitute grave violations of the Fourth Geneva Convention's provisions for medical access [ 9 ].
This theme explores how traditional gender roles and cultural expectations interact with political restrictions to create additional challenges for women's healthcare access. This intersection creates a form of "amplified patriarchy" where political restrictions reinforce and legitimize traditional gender hierarchies.
The permit system amplified patriarchal control, as bureaucratic hurdles reinforced women's dependence on male guardians for mobility permissions [ 3 ]. This integration of political and patriarchal control creates a system of "double confinement" where women's autonomy is constrained by both cultural norms and military restrictions. "My mother-in-law thinks modern doctors interfere too much with natural pregnancy. When checkpoints make it difficult to reach the clinic, she uses this to convince my husband that I don't need regular check-ups." (Participant 2, age 24, Ramallah) "I wanted to see a female gynecologist, but she's in Jerusalem, and I need permits. My husband says it's not worth the trouble for something 'not urgent.' He doesn't understand that reproductive health is important." (Participant 10, age 29, Nablus)
"My mother-in-law thinks modern doctors interfere too much with natural pregnancy. When checkpoints make it difficult to reach the clinic, she uses this to convince my husband that I don't need regular check-ups." (Participant 2, age 24, Ramallah)
"I wanted to see a female gynecologist, but she's in Jerusalem, and I need permits. My husband says it's not worth the trouble for something 'not urgent.' He doesn't understand that reproductive health is important." (Participant 10, age 29, Nablus)
These narratives reveal how political barriers are weaponized within family dynamics to reinforce traditional gender hierarchies and restrict women's healthcare decisions.
Cultural expectations about women's mobility combined with political restrictions to create double barriers for healthcare access. This intersection creates unique vulnerabilities for women, as they face both community pressure to restrict their movement and state-imposed restrictions that make travel dangerous and unpredictable. "As a woman, I'm not supposed to travel alone, especially through checkpoints where soldiers might harass me. But my husband works and can't always come with me to appointments." (Participant 5, age 31, Hebron) "The soldiers at checkpoints sometimes make inappropriate comments to women. This makes families more protective and less willing to let women travel for healthcare." (Participant 13, age 26, Ramallah)
"As a woman, I'm not supposed to travel alone, especially through checkpoints where soldiers might harass me. But my husband works and can't always come with me to appointments." (Participant 5, age 31, Hebron)
"The soldiers at checkpoints sometimes make inappropriate comments to women. This makes families more protective and less willing to let women travel for healthcare." (Participant 13, age 26, Ramallah)
Travel costs to reach healthcare facilities compounded existing gender-based restrictions, particularly affecting women from lower-income households. These economic barriers intersect with both political restrictions and cultural norms to create a system where wealth determines healthcare access, with poor women facing the most severe barriers. "The permit process costs money, then transportation, then sometimes we need to stay overnight near the hospital. My husband says we can't afford all this for 'women's problems' unless it's an emergency." (Participant 1, age 33, Hebron, household income <2,000 NIS) "Rich women can pay for private clinics nearby or take taxis to avoid checkpoint delays. We who are poor have to depend on public transportation and wait in long lines, which makes our families think twice about letting us go." (Participant 9, age 30, Hebron, household income <2,000 NIS)
"The permit process costs money, then transportation, then sometimes we need to stay overnight near the hospital. My husband says we can't afford all this for 'women's problems' unless it's an emergency." (Participant 1, age 33, Hebron, household income <2,000 NIS)
"Rich women can pay for private clinics nearby or take taxis to avoid checkpoint delays. We who are poor have to depend on public transportation and wait in long lines, which makes our families think twice about letting us go." (Participant 9, age 30, Hebron, household income <2,000 NIS)
The economic burden of accessing healthcare was not uniformly distributed. While all women faced travel costs, those from households earning below 2,000 NIS (22.2% of our sample) described making impossible choices between paying for transportation to prenatal check-ups and covering basic household needs. In contrast, women from higher-income households (earning over 6,000 NIS) could afford private taxis that bypassed certain checkpoint delays or pay for overnight accommodation near hospitals in East Jerusalem. This class-based disparity meant that wealthier women, despite facing the same political restrictions, could partially mitigate their effects, while poorer women experienced the full brunt of structural violence.
Movement restrictions trapped women in local healthcare settings, eliminating privacy options for stigmatized services like infertility treatment [ 13 ]. The inability to access distant, anonymous healthcare providers forces women to seek sensitive reproductive services within their communities, exposing them to stigma and social judgment. "In small communities, everyone knows everyone. If you go to the gynecologist, people talk. With limited healthcare options, you can't easily find privacy." (Participant 18, age 37, Nablus) "I needed treatment for infertility, but I was embarrassed to discuss it with the local doctors who know my family. I wanted to go to Jerusalem for privacy, but getting permits is so difficult." (Participant 1, age 33, Hebron)
"In small communities, everyone knows everyone. If you go to the gynecologist, people talk. With limited healthcare options, you can't easily find privacy." (Participant 18, age 37, Nablus)
"I needed treatment for infertility, but I was embarrassed to discuss it with the local doctors who know my family. I wanted to go to Jerusalem for privacy, but getting permits is so difficult." (Participant 1, age 33, Hebron)
Despite significant challenges, women demonstrated remarkable resilience and creativity in navigating healthcare barriers, developing individual and collective strategies for accessing care. However, it is critical to recognize that while these strategies demonstrate women's agency and strength, they simultaneously represent adaptations to systematic state neglect and should not substitute for addressing the underlying structural violations of healthcare rights. Resilience should not be romanticized; it reflects survival under oppressive conditions rather than a solution to systemic injustice.
Informal networks functioned as parallel healthcare infrastructures, compensating for state failure [ 20 ] though this community-based care, while vital for survival, risks normalizing the absence of adequate public healthcare provision. These networks represent creative forms of resistance and collective care, but they also highlight the state's failure to provide essential healthcare services. "My sister lives near the hospital, so I stay with her for my pre-natal appointments. We Palestinian women support each other because we understand the challenges." (Participant 6, age 26, Hebron) "The women in my neighborhood share information about which checkpoints are easier, which doctors are good, and when clinics have special programs. We help each other." (Participant 12, age 31, Nablus)
"My sister lives near the hospital, so I stay with her for my pre-natal appointments. We Palestinian women support each other because we understand the challenges." (Participant 6, age 26, Hebron)
"The women in my neighborhood share information about which checkpoints are easier, which doctors are good, and when clinics have special programs. We help each other." (Participant 12, age 31, Nablus)
Women developed sophisticated strategies for navigating the complex healthcare system and movement restrictions. These strategies represent forms of everyday resistance against the occupation's control over mobility and healthcare access. "I learned to carry all my medical documents and dress professionally when going through checkpoints. I also learned which times of day are better for crossing." (Participant 15, age 34, Ramallah) "I schedule multiple appointments on the same day in the same area to make the most of the permit and checkpoint crossing. I also bring my children for their check-ups at the same time." (Participant 8, age 28, Hebron).
"I learned to carry all my medical documents and dress professionally when going through checkpoints. I also learned which times of day are better for crossing." (Participant 15, age 34, Ramallah)
"I schedule multiple appointments on the same day in the same area to make the most of the permit and checkpoint crossing. I also bring my children for their check-ups at the same time." (Participant 8, age 28, Hebron).
Women with university education (66.7% of our sample) demonstrated more extensive navigation strategies, including using digital health applications, engaging with online advocacy groups, and confidently communicating with military personnel at checkpoints regarding medical urgency. Conversely, women with secondary education or less described greater dependence on family members to manage permit applications and coordinate travel, highlighting how educational capital shapes women's capacity to independently circumvent structural barriers.
Women sought alternative sources of care and support when conventional healthcare was inaccessible. These strategies represent both resourcefulness and the inadequacy of the formal healthcare system. "When I couldn't reach the doctor, I called my cousin who is a nurse. She guided me through some problems and helped me know when something was urgent enough to risk the checkpoint delays." (Participant 4, age 32, Hebron) "I joined online groups where Palestinian women share health information and support each other. It's not the same as seeing a doctor, but it helps when you can't access care." (Participant 17, age 38, Ramallah)
"When I couldn't reach the doctor, I called my cousin who is a nurse. She guided me through some problems and helped me know when something was urgent enough to risk the checkpoint delays." (Participant 4, age 32, Hebron)
"I joined online groups where Palestinian women share health information and support each other. It's not the same as seeing a doctor, but it helps when you can't access care." (Participant 17, age 38, Ramallah)
Some women engaged in advocacy efforts and forms of resistance to challenge barriers and improve access for themselves and other women. These actions represent political resistance against the occupation's control over reproductive healthcare.
"I document my experiences with checkpoint delays when going to medical appointments. I share this information with human rights organizations because our stories need to be heard." (Participant 11, age 27, Nablus).
"I speak openly about reproductive health in my community, even though it's not traditional. Women need information to make good decisions about their health, especially when access to doctors is limited." (Participant 16, age 33, Hebron).
Before discussing the broader implications of our findings, we acknowledge several critical limitations that affect the scope and generalizability of this study.
While we implemented rigorous ethical measures including encrypted data storage, trauma counseling, and conflict-sensitive protocols, we recognize that the reality of ongoing military surveillance may compromise absolute confidentiality guarantees. In contexts where participants may face retaliation for discussing their experiences, the provision of absolute confidentiality cannot be guaranteed, and this ethical limitation must be acknowledged. Similarly, trauma responses among participants could persist beyond the counseling support we provided during the study period.
Most significantly, our study's exclusion of women from Area C villages represents a substantial gap. Area C constitutes approximately 60% of the West Bank and is under full Israeli military and civil control, with the Palestinian Authority having no jurisdictional authority. Women in these areas, who comprise roughly 44% of reproductive-aged females in the West Bank [ 21 ], face the most severe access restrictions, including having to cross multiple checkpoints just to leave their villages, lack of nearby primary healthcare facilities, and frequent military closures that cut off entire communities for days. Our study, conducted in Areas A and B (where the Palestinian Authority has civil or security control), cannot capture these extreme experiences.
Similarly, the exclusion of Gaza due to security constraints means our findings cannot represent the qualitatively different and more severe healthcare access landscape under comprehensive siege. Future research must employ community-led participatory methodologies and secure safe access protocols to ensure the voices of these most marginalized populations are centered in academic discourse, rather than inadvertently excluded from the evidence base.
Our sampling also skewed toward women with secondary education or higher (66.7%), potentially under-representing the experiences of women with limited literacy who may face additional barriers in navigating healthcare systems and advocating for their needs.
The geographic concentration in three main areas, while providing depth, limits understanding of the diverse experiences across the West Bank's varied landscape of restrictions. Future research must employ community-led methodologies to safely access these high-risk populations and ensure their voices are not marginalized in academic discourse.
Introduction
Palestinian women in the West Bank navigate complex challenges in accessing reproductive and maternal healthcare within the context of a prolonged Israeli military occupation that has persisted since 1967. The intersection of gender, conflict, and healthcare access creates unique vulnerabilities that have profound implications for women’s health outcomes and reproductive rights [ 1 ]. Understanding these experiences requires examining how macro-level political structures interact with micro-level individual experiences to shape women's healthcare journeys.
The occupied Palestinian territories, particularly the West Bank, present a unique healthcare landscape characterized by systematic fragmentation, restrictions, and bureaucratic barriers that disproportionately affect women's access to essential reproductive health services [ 2 ]. Unlike other conflict zones such as Syria or Yemen where healthcare barriers primarily result from active warfare and infrastructure destruction, the West Bank's Israeli-imposed institutionalized permit system creates a distinct form of administrative control over medical access. This bureaucratic weaponization of healthcare differs fundamentally from the more chaotic but less systematically controlled barriers found in active conflict zones. The Israeli military administers a comprehensive permit regime that governs Palestinian movement, including access to healthcare facilities, creating a system where medical access becomes contingent on military authorization rather than medical necessity [ 3 , 4 ].
To provide essential context for readers unfamiliar with the Palestinian situation, the term "Intifada" (Arabic: انتفاضة, literally "shaking off") refers to two major Palestinian uprisings against Israeli occupation. The First Intifada (1987–1993) involved widespread civil disobedience, strikes, and protests across the occupied territories, significantly disrupting daily life and healthcare access through curfews, closures, and military responses that limited movement and medical service delivery [ 5 ]. The Second Intifada (2000–2005) was more militarized and coincided with a significant escalation of Israeli military measures, including the extensive construction of the separation wall, the expansion of checkpoints, the intensification of the permit system, and the reoccupation of Palestinian urban centers [ 5 ]. While both uprisings profoundly affected healthcare access, the Second Intifada marked a qualitative shift toward the permanent institutionalization of movement restrictions through the permit regime and physical barriers that continue to fragment the West Bank today. The expansion of Israeli settlements accelerated during this period, further fracturing Palestinian geography and creating additional layers of access restrictions.
Since the Second Intifada in 2000, the healthcare system in the West Bank has faced increasing challenges due to the expansion of Israeli settlements, the construction of the separation wall, and the implementation of an Israeli military-administered permit system that controls Palestinian movement [ 5 ]. These measures have created what researchers describe as a "fragmented healthcare geography" [ 6 ], where the proximity of healthcare facilities does not guarantee access, and women must navigate multiple checkpoints and lengthy bureaucratic processes to receive care. Figure 1 illustrates the fragmented geography of the West Bank, including the route of the Israeli separation wall, the locations of permanent military checkpoints, the distribution of Israeli settlements, and the Area A/B/C administrative divisions, providing geographical context for the structural barriers to healthcare access discussed throughout this study. Fig. 1 Geographic fragmentation of the West Bank showing the route of the Israeli separation wall, permanent military checkpoints, Israeli settlements, and the Area A/B/C administrative divisions. Simplified and adapted from the United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs, West Bank Access Restrictions , November 2024 [ 7 ]
Geographic fragmentation of the West Bank showing the route of the Israeli separation wall, permanent military checkpoints, Israeli settlements, and the Area A/B/C administrative divisions. Simplified and adapted from the United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs, West Bank Access Restrictions , November 2024 [ 7 ]
This study is explicitly informed by reproductive justice theory as situated within a settler colonial context [ 8 ], which posits that reproductive health encompasses not merely the right to choose whether to have children, but the right to have children, not have children, and parent children safely within supportive communities. In the Palestinian context, reproductive justice requires examining how Israeli occupation policies systematically undermine all three pillars of reproductive justice: (1) the right to have children, compromised through restricted access to prenatal and obstetric care; (2) the right not to have children, limited by barriers to family planning services; and (3) the right to parent safely, undermined by the broader conditions of territorial control, dispossession, and systemic insecurity. This theoretical framework guides our research questions by examining how military occupation systematically compromises reproductive autonomy, health outcomes, and parenting conditions through structural barriers.
The healthcare restrictions documented in the occupied Palestinian territory have been described as inconsistent with, or as raising concerns under, several international legal frameworks that protect healthcare access. These include the Fourth Geneva Convention (Article 56), which obligates occupying powers to ensure medical care for protected persons; the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (Article 12), which guarantees the right to health; and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (Article 25), which affirms the right to medical care [ 9 ]. The documented permit restrictions, delays in emergency medical access, and fragmentation of healthcare services have been argued to be inconsistent with these international obligations.
The impact of these restrictions extends beyond mere inconvenience, affecting fundamental aspects of reproductive health including prenatal care, delivery services, family planning, and emergency obstetric care. Women in rural areas face particular challenges, as they may need to travel significant distances and cross multiple checkpoints to reach specialized healthcare facilities, often located in urban centers like Ramallah or East Jerusalem [ 10 , 11 ].
Research on women's health in conflict settings has documented the disproportionate impact of political violence and restrictions on women's reproductive health outcomes. Studies from various conflict contexts have shown that women face increased risks of maternal mortality, reduced access to contraception, delayed prenatal care, and limited access to skilled birth attendants [ 12 ]. However, the occupation-specific bureaucratic systems in the Palestinian context, including the Israeli military permit regime and permanent checkpoint infrastructure, create distinct structural barriers that require specific examination [ 13 ].
The Palestinian healthcare system operates under complex governance structures, with multiple providers including the Palestinian Authority Ministry of Health, United Nations Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA), non-governmental organizations, and private providers. This fragmentation, while providing some redundancy in services, also creates systemic coordination challenges and compromises care continuity [ 14 ], particularly affecting women who require ongoing care throughout pregnancy and reproductive life cycles amid mobility restrictions.
Administrative weaponization through checkpoint delays imposed by Israeli military forces represents one of the most significant barriers to healthcare access for Palestinian women. Reports have documented cases of women giving birth at checkpoints due to delays in reaching healthcare facilities, highlighting the life-threatening consequences of movement restrictions that violate international humanitarian law's requirement for unimpeded access to medical care [ 15 , 16 ]. These experiences create lasting trauma and contribute to women's reluctance to seek care, further compromising health outcomes.
The permit system administered by Israeli military authorities adds another layer of complexity to healthcare access. Palestinian women from certain areas require special permits to access healthcare facilities in East Jerusalem or Israel, where some of the most advanced medical services are available. The permit application process is often lengthy, unpredictable, and may be denied without explanation, leaving women without access to specialized care [ 17 , 18 ].
Cultural and social factors further complicate women's healthcare access within this political context. Traditional gender roles in Palestinian society, which include expectations that women prioritize family needs, seek male guardian approval for medical decisions, and face restrictions on traveling alone, intersect with structural barriers to create additional challenges [ 19 ]. Women may face restrictions on traveling alone to healthcare appointments, require male guardian approval for certain medical procedures, or experience pressure to prioritize family needs over their own healthcare requirements. These traditional norms become amplified through integration with the military permit system, creating a form of "double confinement" where cultural expectations and political restrictions collectively constrain women's mobility and healthcare access.
Despite these challenges, Palestinian women have developed sophisticated strategies for navigating healthcare barriers, demonstrating remarkable resilience and adaptability. Community networks, family support systems, and informal healthcare arrangements often serve as crucial resources for women seeking reproductive healthcare [ 20 ]. Understanding these adaptive strategies is essential for developing interventions that build upon existing strengths and resources.
Previous research on Palestinian women's health has often focused on quantitative measures of health outcomes or clinical indicators. While these studies provide important epidemiological data, there remains a significant gap in woman-centered qualitative evidence capturing lived experiences of navigating reproductive healthcare under occupation [ 4 ]. Phenomenological research centering women's voices is essential to understand how political, social, and cultural factors co-constitute barriers to reproductive justice [ 8 ].
This study addresses this gap by employing a phenomenological approach to explore how Palestinian women in the West Bank experience and navigate reproductive healthcare access within the context of Israeli military occupation. By focusing on women's lived experiences, this research aims to provide insights that can inform gender-sensitive healthcare policies, improve service delivery, and support advocacy efforts for Palestinian women's reproductive rights.
The West Bank context, with its diverse geographical, economic, and political characteristics, provides an ideal setting for exploring these experiences. Urban areas like Ramallah and Bethlehem offer different healthcare access patterns compared to rural villages, while areas near Israeli settlements face particular restrictions [ 21 ]. This diversity allows for exploration of how different contextual factors influence women's healthcare experiences.