Results
A total of
361 plasma and 261 follicular fluid samples were collected from enrolled
participants. Following sample matching, 222 paired plasma-follicular
fluid sets were retained for BFTE analysis. From the follicular fluid
cohort, a case-control study was established, comprising 92 individuals
diagnosed with DOR and 92 age- and BMI-matched controls. Baseline
demographic and exposure characteristics of the matched cohort are
summarized in Table
. The DOR group had a median age of 33.0 years and a median BMI of
22.6 kg/m 2 , while the control group had corresponding values
of 34.0 years and 22.5 kg/m 2 . Median infertility duration
was 3.0 years in both groups. Statistically significant differences
were observed between groups for educational attainment, physical
activity frequency, exposure to rubber or plastic products, exposure
to disinfectant, and egg consumption frequency ( p < 0.05). In contrast, no significant differences were detected
in menstrual cycle characteristics (duration, cycle length, or flow),
household income, smoking status, alcohol consumption, fish intake,
history of spontaneous abortion, or parity ( p ≥
0.05).
Abbreviations: BMI, body mass index; n = sample size.
Among the PFAS detected in matched plasma
and follicular fluid samples, 15 compounds with detection rates exceeding
50% in both matrices were retained for BFTE analysis ( Tables S4, S5 ). This subset consisted of eight
PFCA (PFBA, PFHpA, PFOA, PFNA, PFDA, PFUnDA, PFDoDA, and PFTriDA),
two PFECA (PFMOAA and PFO5DoDA), three PFSA (PFHxS, PFHpS, and PFOS),
and two PFESA (6:2 Cl-PFESA and 8:2 Cl-PFESA) ( Table S6 ). PFOA exhibited the highest median concentration
across all PFAS analytes, measuring 3.50 ng/mL in follicular fluid
and 4.55 ng/mL in plasma, followed by PFOS at 2.78 ng/mL and 3.73
ng/mL, respectively. The alternative compound 6:2 Cl-PFESA also showed
relatively high levels, with median concentrations of 0.88 ng/mL in
follicular fluid and 1.20 ng/mL in plasma ( Table S6 ; Figure
A,B).
Concentrations of PFAS detected in human follicular fluid samples
and in the paired plasma samples. (A) Concentrations of PFAS in human
follicular fluid samples. (B) Concentrations of PFAS in the paired
plasma samples. (C) Distribution levels of main PFAS in follicular
fluid of case and control participants. Corresponding raw data are
presented in Tables S6 and S7 .
Within the case-control cohort, 13 PFCA/PFECA (PFBA,
PFPeA, PFHxA,
PFHpA, PFMOAA, PFOA, PFNA, PFDA, PFUnDA, PFDoDA, PFTriDA, PFTeDA,
and PFO5DoDA) and six PFSA/PFESA (PFBS, PFHxS, PFHpS, PFOS, 6:2 Cl-PFESA,
and 8:2 Cl-PFESA) were detected in more than 50% of follicular fluid
samples ( Table S7 ). PFOA and PFOS remained
the dominant species, with median concentrations of 3.75 ng/mL (cases:
3.44 ng/mL; controls: 3.92 ng/mL) and 2.84 ng/mL (cases: 2.82 ng/mL;
controls: 2.84 ng/mL), respectively. Several emerging compounds, including
PFMOAA (0.96 ng/mL) and 6:2 Cl-PFESA (0.88 ng/mL), were present at
appreciable concentrations. Comparative analysis revealed significant
group differences for PFBA, PFPeA, PFTeDA, PFBS, and PFHxS ( p < 0.05, Table S7 ), with
the DOR group exhibiting elevated levels of PFBA and PFPeA relative
to controls ( Figure
C).
Transfer efficiency of PFAS from blood to follicle and its association
with chain length. (A) Blood-follicle transfer efficiencies of PFAS.
(B) Simple linear regression model examining the association of chain
length with transfer efficiencies for PFAS with detection rates more
than 50%. Corresponding raw data are presented in Table S6 .
Pearson correlation analysis stratified by carboxylic
and sulfonic
acid classes revealed distinct clustering patterns. Strong positive
correlations were observed among short-chain PFCA/PFECA (PFBA, PFPeA,
PFHxA, and PFMOAA), with coefficients ranging from 0.60 to 0.88. Long-chain
PFCA/PFECA exhibited even stronger correlations, with the strongest
correlation observed between PFDoDA and PFUnDA ( r = 0.94). A similar trend was observed among sulfonic acids, with
long-chain PFSA/PFESA compounds exhibiting moderate to strong correlations
( r = 0.57–0.84) and short-chain compounds
such as PFBS and PFHxS exhibiting weaker associations ( r = 0.29). These correlation structures suggest that PFAS with similar
chemical properties may share common exposure pathways or exhibit
analogous transport dynamics.
Median BFTEs across the 15 PFAS
compounds ranged from 62.43% to
470.93% ( Figure
A; Table S6 ), revealing a distinct chain-length-dependent
pattern. Among PFCA, a pronounced inverse relationship was observed
between carbon chain length and BFTE, with transfer efficiencies exceeding
100% restricted to short-chain PFCA and all PFECA, descending in the
order PFBA (470.93%), PFMOAA (418.08%), PFO5DoDA (146.52%), and PFHpA
(135.44%). In contrast, PFSA and PFESA displayed substantially lower
transfer efficiencies, with PFHxS reaching 84.61% and 8:2 Cl-PFESA
showing the lowest value at 62.43%. Simple linear regression analysis
substantiated a significant inverse relationship between carbon chain
length and BFTE [β = −0.31 (95% CI: −0.52, −0.11)],
indicating that molecular size exerts a constraining effect on PFAS
passage across the blood-follicle barrier ( Figure
B).
Associations between specific PFAS and
DOR are shown in Table S8 and Figure
. Fully adjusted
logistic regression models identified strong positive associations
between short-chain PFCA and PFECA, notably PFBA and PFPeA, and the
likelihood of DOR, with ORs of 1.58 (95% CI: 1.22, 2.05) and 1.36
(95% CI: 1.12, 1.65) per unit increase in ln-transformed concentration,
respectively. In contrast, inverse associations were observed for
several long-chain compounds, including PFTriDA (OR: 0.57, 95% CI:
0.33, 0.99), PFTeDA (OR: 0.36, 95% CI: 0.18, 0.73), and PFHxS (OR:
0.56, 95% CI: 0.32, 0.98). Analysis of AMH concentrations revealed
divergent trends across PFAS compounds. Significant negative associations
with AMH were observed for PFBA, PFPeA, and PFMOAA, whereas positive
associations emerged for PFOA, PFUnDA, PFDoDA, PFTriDA, PFTeDA, PFHxS,
6:2 Cl-PFESA, and 8:2 Cl-PFESA ( Table S9 ; Figure
). Poisson
regression models assessing AFC demonstrated significant reductions
associated with short-chain PFAS exposure: each ln-unit increase in
PFBA, PFPeA, PFHxA, and PFMOAA corresponded to significant declines
in AFC to 91%, 94%, 95%, and 93% of baseline values, respectively
( Table S10 ; Figure
).
Associations of individual PFAS exposure in
follicular fluid with
DOR and ovarian reserve parameters (AMH, AFC). Odds ratios (ORs) for
DOR were derived from conditional logistic regression; β coefficients
for AMH from multiple linear regression; and incidence rate ratio
(IRR) for AFC from Poisson regression. The numbers in the figure represent
the effect sizes from the regression analyses. Note: All models were
adjusted for educational level, physical exercise frequency, exposure
to rubber and plastic products, exposure to disinfectants, and egg
consumption, abortion, and parturition. Linear and Poisson regression
were additionally adjusted for age and BMI. *: p <
0.05, **: p < 0.01, ***: p <
0.001. The numerical values are presented in Tables S9–S11 .
Quartile-based analyses further substantiated the
associations
identified in continuous exposure models ( Table S11 ). Elevated DOR risk was observed in the third and fourth
quartiles of PFBA concentrations and across all quartiles of PFPeA,
with significant dose–response trends ( p <
0.05). In contrast, PFBS exhibited an inverse relationship with DOR
risk relative to the lowest quartile. AMH concentrations declined
markedly with increasing exposure to short-chain compounds, including
PFBA, PFPeA, PFHxA, and PFMOAA. Conversely, progressive elevations
in AMH were observed across higher quartiles of several long-chain
PFAS, including PFOA, PFUnDA, PFDoDA, PFTriDA, PFO5DoDA, PFBS, PFHxS,
PFHpS, and PFOS. In quartile-based analyses of AFC, significant inverse
dose–response trends were identified for short-chain PFCA/PFECA
and PFDA.
To investigate potential nonlinear exposure-response
relationships,
RCS models were constructed using knots at the fifth, 35th, 65th,
and 95th percentiles ( Figures S4, S5 ).
PFHpA was excluded due to insufficient effective knots compromising
spline structure stability. Analysis revealed a significant inverted
U-shaped association between PFUnDA and DOR risk ( Figure S4 ), while PFOA, PFNA, PFDA, and PFUnDA all demonstrated
significant U-shaped relationships with AMH concentrations ( Figure S5 ).
As shown in Figure
A, increasing PFAS mixture concentrations
were positively associated with the risk of DOR. Each quartile increment
in the mixture index corresponded to an OR of 2.00 (95% CI: 1.24,
3.22) for DOR ( Figure
A; Table S12 ). WQS regression identified
PFBA as the dominant contributor (58.40%), followed by PFNA, PFO5DoDA,
and PFOA ( Figure
A; Table S13 ). BKMR analysis supported these findings,
revealing a monotonic increase in DOR risk with rising mixture exposure
levels ( Figure
B).
Posterior inclusion probability analysis further highlighted short-chain
PFCA/PFECA as the most influential group (groupPIP = 1.000), with
PFBA exhibiting the highest conditional probability (condPIP = 0.7558)
( Table S14 ). In single-exposure modeling,
an increase in PFBA from the 25th to 75th percentile was most strongly
associated with DOR ( Figure S6 ). Univariate
exposure-response functions confirmed a pronounced positive relationship
between PFBA and DOR, with a steep dose–response curve ( Figure S7 ). No meaningful interaction effects
were detected among PFAS compounds, as the concentration–response
slopes remained stable across coexposure levels ( Figure S8 ). Although inverse trends were noted between total
PFAS mixture exposure and both AMH and AFC, these associations did
not reach statistical significance ( Figure
C, D).
Associations of PFAS mixture with DOR,
AMH, and AFC ( n = 184). (A) WQS analysis of the associations
between the follicular
fluid PFAS mixture and DOR. (B) Associations between the follicular
fluid PFAS mixture and DOR calculated by BKMR. (C) WQS analysis of
the associations between the follicular fluid PFAS mixture and AMH.
(D) WQS analysis of the associations between the follicular fluid
PFAS mixture and AFC. Note: WQS and BKMR models for DOR were adjusted
for educational level, physical exercise frequency, exposure to rubber
and plastic products, exposure to disinfectants, and egg consumption,
abortion, and parturition. Models for AMH and AFC were further adjusted
for age and BMI.
Targeted analysis of the short-chain PFCA/PFECA
subgrouppreviously
identified as key contributorswas applied to isolate their
effects on ovarian reserve. In the WQS model constrained for positive
direction, a one-unit increase in the short-chain PFCA/PFECA mixture
index was associated with a significantly elevated DOR risk (OR =
1.88), with PFBA again emerging as the primary driver ( Figure
A; Tables S12, S15 ). The mixture index was also negatively associated
with AMH concentrations (β = −1.28), with PFHpA and PFBA
contributing the highest weights ( Figure
B; Tables S12, S15 ). For AFC, increasing mixture concentrations corresponded to a reduction
to 92% of baseline values, again predominantly attributable to PFBA
( Figure
C; Tables S12, S15 ). All WQS models focused on the
short-chain PFCA/PFECA subset yielded statistically significant results,
and detailed weights and estimates are provided in Tables S12 and S15 . These key contributorsparticularly
PFBAwere consistently identified across both the full mixture
and the short-chain-specific WQS models. For comparative analysis,
WQS models were also constructed for long-chain PFCA/PFECA and PFSA/PFESA.
These showed divergent directions of association with DOR and AMH,
while AFC tended to decrease in all models except for the negatively
constrained long-chain PFCA/PFECA model, in which AFC showed a modest
increase with greater mixture exposure ( Tables S12, S16, S17 ).
Associations of short-chain PFCA/PFECA mixture with DOR,
AMH, and
AFC ( n = 184). (A) WQS analysis of the associations
between the follicular fluid short-chain PFCA/PFECA mixture and DOR.
(B) WQS analysis of the associations between the follicular fluid
short-chain PFCA/PFECA mixture and AMH. (C) WQS analysis of the associations
between the follicular fluid short-chain PFCA/PFECA mixture and AFC.
Note: WQS models for DOR were adjusted for educational level, physical
exercise frequency, exposure to rubber and plastic products, exposure
to disinfectants, and egg consumption, abortion, and parturition Models
for AMH and AFC were further adjusted age and BMI.
To
address multicollinearity among PFAS concentrations in follicular
fluid, PCA was conducted ( Table S18 ). Components
with eigenvalues exceeding 1 were retained, yielding four principal
components that individually explained 48.70%, 16.98%, 5.99%, and
5.73% of total variance, respectively. The cumulative variance explained
by these four components was 77.40% (PC1:48.70%, PC1+PC2:65.68%, PC1+PC2+PC3:71.67%,
PC1+PC2+PC3+PC4:77.40%) ( Table S19 ). PC1
primarily captured variation in long-chain PFCA/PFECA and PFSA/PFESA,
excluding PFBS. PC2 was largely driven by short-chain PFCA/PFECA,
with the exception of PFHpA. PC3 and PC4 were predominantly defined
by PFBS and PFHpA respectively. PCR identified significant associations
between specific PCs and ovarian reserve indicators ( Table S20 ). Both PC2 and PC4 were positively associated with
the likelihood of DOR. For AMH, a positive association was observed
with PC1, while PC2 showed a negative relationship. In the analysis
of AFC, only PC2 demonstrated a statistically significant inverse
association.
Materials
Reproductive-aged women (≤40 years) receiving clinical care
at Shengjing Hospital in Shenyang, China, between 2017 and 2020 were
enrolled in this study. Matched plasma and follicular fluid samples
were collected from each participant whenever possible. All participants
were fully informed of the study procedures and provided written informed
consent. The Ethics Review Committee of Shengjing Hospital of China
Medical University approved this study (Approval No.: 2019PS024F).
Sample collection occurred on the day of oocyte retrieval, and participants
voluntarily provided the paired biological samples. After exclusion
of follicular fluid samples with insufficient volume or blood contamination,
a total of 361 plasma and 261 follicular fluid samples were available
for analysis. Details of the participant pairing protocol are presented
in Figure S1 .
Clinical data were
extracted from electronic medical records by uniformly trained personnel
following completion of IVF cycles. In accordance with clinical requirements
and to eliminate the potential confounding due to differences in bilateral
follicle development, follicular fluid samples were aspirated during
oocyte retrieval by puncturing the dominant follicle in the left ovary.
To avoid contamination or dilution by flushing media during double-lumen
needle aspiration, only the initial aspirate was collected. Approximately
1–2 mL of follicular fluid was obtained and centrifuged at
3 000 r/min for 5 min. The supernatant was transferred into 500 μL
microcentrifuge tubes and stored at – 80 °C for subsequent
analysis.
A total of 32 PFAS were quantified, including C4–C12
perfluorocarboxylic acids (PFCA) [PFBA, perfluoropentanoic acid (PFPeA),
perfluorohexanoic acid (PFHxA), PFHpA, PFOA, perfluorononanoic acid
(PFNA), perfluorodecanoic acid (PFDA), perfluoroundecanoic acid (PFUnDA),
perfluorododecanoic acid (PFDoDA), perfluorotridecanoic acid (PFTriDA),
and perfluorotetradecanoic acid (PFTeDA)]; perfluorosulfonic acids
(PFSA) with carbon chain lengths of 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, and 10 [PFBS, perfluoropentanesulfonic
acid (PFPeS), perfluorohexanesulfonic acid (PFHxS), perfluoroheptanesulfonic
acid (PFHpS), PFOS, and perfluorodecanesulfonic acid (PFDS)]; 13 PFECA
[hexafluoropropylene oxide dimer acid (HFPO–DA), perfluoro-2,5-dimethyl-3,6-dioxo-heptanoic
acid (HFPO-TrA (C7)), perfluoro-2,5-dimethyl-3,6-dioxo-octanoic acid
(HFPO-TrA (C8)), hexafluoropropylene oxide trimer acid (HFPO-TrA (C9)),
hexafluoropropylene oxide tetramer acid (HFPO-TeA), perfluoro-2-methoxyacetic
acid (PFMOAA), perfluoro-(3,5,7,9-tetraoxadecanoic) acid (PFO4PeA),
perfluoro-5-oxahexanoic acid (PF5OHxA), perfluoro-(3,5-dioxahexanoic)
acid (PFO2HxA), perfluoro-3,6-dioxaheptanoic acid (3,6-OPFHpA), perfluoro-(3,5,7-trioxaoctanoic)
acid (PFO3OA), perfluoro-(3,5,7,9-tetraoxadecanoic) acid (PFO4DA),
and perfluoro-3,5,7,9,11-pentaoxadodecanoic acid (PFO5DoDA)]; and
3 PFESA [4:2 chlorinated polyfluoroalkyl ether sulfonic acid (4:2
Cl-PFESA), 6:2 chlorinated polyfluorinated ether sulfonate (6:2 Cl-PFESA),
and potassium 11-chloroheicosafluoro-3-oxanonane-1-sulfonate (8:2
Cl-PFESA)]. Analytical protocols followed a previously published method. After thawing at 4 °C, plasma and follicular
fluid samples were vortexed and centrifuged to eliminate fibrin precipitates
generated during the freeze–thaw process. We added 5 μL
(0.5 ng) of a mixed internal standard working solution and 1 mL of
acetonitrile into 200 μL of plasma or 400 μL of follicular
fluid samples, respectively. After ultrasonic treatment, vortex mixing,
and centrifugation, the supernatant was collected. The extraction
procedure was repeated, and combined supernatants were evaporated
to dryness under a gentle nitrogen stream. Redissolve the residue
in 200 μL of methanol–water, vortex (2 000 r/min, 2 min),
and then centrifuge (4 400 r/min, 15 min). Transfer 100 μL of
the supernatant into a vial for instrumental analysis. Target PFAS
were measured using ultrahigh performance liquid chromatography-tandem
mass spectrometry (UHPLC-MS/MS, AB SCIEX 6500, Framingham, MA, USA).
Details on the chromatographic columns and instrument parameters are
provided in Tables S1, S2 .
Comprehensive
quality assurance and control (QA/QC) procedures were implemented
to ensure accurate PFAS quantification. One procedural blank was included
in each batch of 20 samples to monitor potential background contamination.
Quality control materials (SRM1957 for plasma and pooled control samples
for follicular fluid) were analyzed with each batch to evaluate data
reliability. Calibration standards (0.1, 1, and 10 ng/mL) were analyzed
every 40 samples to monitor chromatographic system performance. Limits
of quantification (LOQs) ranged from 0.01–0.02 ng/mL for plasma
and 0.005–0.01 ng/mL for follicular fluid. Matrix spike recovery
rates ranged from 82.29%–115.21% for plasma and 80.42%–118.76%
for follicular fluid.
Plasma and follicular fluid samples were paired to
generate matched sets for evaluating PFAS partitioning between the
two biological matrices. The BFTEs were calculated as the ratio of
PFAS concentrations in follicular fluid to those in plasma. To enhance
estimation accuracy, only analytes with detection frequencies exceeding
50% in paired samples were included in BFTE calculations. Compounds
with a detection rate lower than 50% in any matrix were excluded,
including PFPeA, PFHxA, PFTeDA, PFBS, PFPeS, PFO4PeA and 4:2 Cl-PFESA.
Avoid potential bias due to low exposure levels where most of the
data rely on imputation. Associations between PFAS carbon chain length
and BFTE values were examined using simple linear regression models.
DOR currently lacks universally standardized
diagnostic criteria, although it is commonly defined by reduced AMH,
low AFC, and elevated FSH. For this study, DOR was diagnosed when
at least one of the following conditions was met: AFC < 6 or AMH
12 U/L is recognized as an auxiliary
diagnostic marker, it was not used for classification due to the requirement
for repeated measurements to ensure reliability. Case exclusion criteria
were: (a) Age ≥ 40 years or BMI > 30 kg/m 2 ; (b)
clinical diagnosis of polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS), premature
ovarian insufficiency (POI), endometriosis, adenomyosis, thyroid disorders,
hyperprolactinemia, or hyperglycemia; (c) prior ovarian surgery, tuberculosis,
or bilateral salpingectomy; and (d) missing baseline serum sex hormone
data. Control inclusion criteria were: (a) age ≤ 40 years and
BMI < 30 kg/m 2 ; (b) no history of recurrent miscarriage;
(c) absence of exclusion conditions (b–d); and (d) undergoing
assisted reproduction for male-factor infertility. Cases and controls
were matched 1:1 using SPSS software based on age (±1 year) and
BMI (±1 kg/m 2 ). Detailed matching results are presented
in Table S3 .
Covariates were
identified using both directed acyclic graphs and statistical comparisons
( Figure S2 ). Independent samples t -tests (for continuous variables) and chi-square tests
(for categorical variables) were applied to compare potential confounders
between groups, excluding samples with missing data and omitting categorical
variable groups with incidence below 5%. Variables showing significant
between-group differences ( p < 0.05) were retained
as covariates and included educational attainment, physical activity
frequency, exposure to disinfectants, exposure to rubber and plastic
products, and egg consumption. Furthermore, given established evidence
linking abortion history and prior parturition to PFAS accumulation
and ovarian function, these two continuous variables were also incorporated
as control factors in subsequent analyses.
Descriptive
statistics were employed to characterize the demographic profiles
and PFAS concentrations in both case and control groups. Categorical
variables were presented as frequencies and percentages, while continuous
variables were reported as medians with interquartile ranges (25th–75th
percentiles). All continuous variables underwent normality assessment
prior to statistical analysis. PFAS and AMH concentrations exhibited
skewed distributions. Therefore, group differences in PFAS concentrations
were assessed using the Wilcoxon rank-sum test. Only compounds detected
in more than 50% of follicular fluid samples were retained for further
statistical analysis. Values below the LOQ were imputed as LOQ divided
by
√ 2
. For multivariate models requiring the
assumption of normality, all follicular fluid PFAS concentrations
and AMH values were natural log (ln)-transformed. The skewness of
the transformed data decreased, and Shapiro-Wilk tests indicated that
most variables followed a normal distribution ( p >
0.05), supporting the use of parametric methods. Pearson correlation
coefficients were calculated to examine intercorrelations among ln-transformed
PFAS analytes.
To assess the association between individual
PFAS and ovarian reserve outcomes, multivariable regression models
were used and provided effect estimates. Logistic regression was used
to estimate the odds ratios (ORs) of DOR, multiple linear regression
was applied to model AMH levels, and Poisson regression to calculate
the incidence rate ratios of AFC. Covariate adjustment followed a
three-tiered strategy: unadjusted crude model; Model 1 adjusted for
educational attainment, physical activity, exposure to rubber and
plastic products, exposure to disinfectants, and egg consumption;
and Model 2, which additionally adjusted for obstetric history, including
prior childbirth and abortion. For linear and Poisson regression analyses,
all models additionally controlled for age and BMI. In addition, to
evaluate the trend of ovarian reserve outcomes with PFAS quartile,
we treated the median value of each PFAS quartile as a continuous
variable and calculated the p -trend. Restricted cubic
spline (RCS) regression was also employed to examine nonlinear dose–response
relationships between ln-transformed PFAS levels and DOR.
To
evaluate the joint effects of PFAS exposure, weighted quantitative
sum (WQS) regression and Bayesian kernel machine regression (BKMR)
models were employed. WQS regression was set as primary method to
constructs a weighted index representing combined exposure to multiple
PFAS, allowing estimation of the joint association with outcomes and
quantification of the relative contribution of each compound. In the
WQS model, exposure data were randomly partitioned into a 40% training
set for weight derivation and a 60% validation set for association
testing, with 500 bootstrap iterations to enhance parameter stability. However, this model requires the assumption
that the effects of all compounds are in the same direction. Using
BKMR as a supplement allows for flexible modeling of potentially nonlinear
relationships and interactions among mixture components, without requiring the effect directions in advance.
Given the high collinearity among PFAS, stratified BKMR analyses were
performed by chemical class: short-chain PFCA/PFECA, long-chain PFCA/PFECA,
and PFSA/PFESA. All BKMR models were implemented using a Markov chain
Monte Carlo (MCMC) algorithm with 10 000 iterations to ensure posterior
convergence.
To address multicollinearity, we conducted principal
component
regression (PCR) by integrating principal component analysis (PCA)
with multiple regression. Data were Z-score normalized, and components
with eigenvalues greater than 1 (per Kaiser criterion) were retained
for inclusion in the regression models. This method can identify potential
exposure patterns of PFAS and assess the association between these
patterns and outcomes.
WQS, BKMR, and RCS analyses were conducted
in R v4.4.1 (R Development
Core Team) using the packages “gWQS”, “bkmr”,
and “plotRCS”, respectively. All other statistical analyses
were performed using SPSS v27.0 (SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL, USA). A two-sided p -value <0.05 was considered statistically significant.
Conclusion
This study provides the
first evidence that PFECA (PFMOAA and PFO5DoDA)
are present in human follicular fluid, demonstrating that short-chain
and alternative perfluoroalkyl ether carboxylic acids can cross the
blood-follicle barrier. Analyses identified a significant positive
correlation between PFAS exposure and DOR risk, with short-chain PFCA/PFECA
serving as the principal contributors and PFBA exerting the strongest
influence. These findings advance current understanding of the reproductive
hazards associated with short-chain and alternative PFAS and highlight
the importance of incorporating these compounds into future risk-assessment
frameworks.
Discussion
Widespread detection of
both legacy and emerging PFAS in human
follicular fluid provides direct evidence for their translocation
across the blood-follicle barrier, implying potential risk of exposure
to oocytes. A statistically robust association was observed between
PFAS mixture burden and elevated risk of DOR. Notably, compound-specific
exposure-response patterns were detected, with short-chain PFCA/PFECA
species showing preferential accumulation in follicular fluid and
exerting a marked influence on DOR risk, predominantly by PFBA.
Despite global restrictions on PFOA and PFOS under the Stockholm
Convention, these substances remained
the predominant PFAS detected in follicular fluid. However, concentrations
in this cohort were lower than those reported in multiple Chinese
populations, including 6.54 ng/mL and 3.13 ng/mL in infertile women
in Shanghai, 5.56 ng/mL and 4.28 ng/mL
in IVF-ET patients in Yantai and Beijing, and 4.35 ng/mL and 5.22 ng/mL in PCOS patients in Xiamen. Compared with European data sets, PFOA levels
were lower, while PFOS concentrations were comparable with values
reported in Sweden and Estonia. In addition
to legacy compounds, this study is the first to have identified PFMOAA
and PFO5DoDA in human follicular fluid, with detection frequencies
exceeding 90% of samples. These high detection frequencies, combined
with strong BFTEs, highlight the substantial biological accessibility
of novel ether-based PFAS. Furthermore, 6:2 Cl-PFESA, a widely used
PFOS replacement in the electroplating sector, was detected at concentrations
similar to or exceeding those of several long-chain PFCA. Median levels
exceeded those reported in Guangxi (0.452 ng/mL) but were slightly lower than those measured in Beijing
(1.09 ng/mL) and Yantai (2.16 ng/mL), reflecting a distinct exposure profile among
Chinese populations.
PFAS distribution between plasma and follicular
fluid exhibited
clear chain length-dependent partitioning, consistent with prior findings
in IVF cohorts from Guangxi and Beijing. BFTEs decreased with increasing chain length,
with short-chain PFCA and all PFECA species demonstrating markedly
higher transfer efficiencies. These patterns suggest preferential
accumulation in follicular fluid compared to plasma, potentially due
to the binding characteristics of serum albumin.
,
Compounds with lower binding affinity and smaller molecular dimensionscharacteristic
of short-chain PFASmore readily accumulate in follicular fluid.
In contrast, long-chain compounds exhibit strong albumin binding that
reduces the freely dissolved fraction available for transfer. A previous study has shown that the logKow of
PFAS is significantly negatively associated with its BFTEs, suggesting that the higher lipophilicity of
long-chain PFAS further restricts their transfer efficiencies. The
lower BFTEs of sulfonic acids relative to carboxylic acids of comparable
carbon chain length are likely attributable to the stronger binding
affinity of PFOS for serum albumin compared to PFOA.
,
Although direct measurements of albumin binding for ether-based
PFAS are limited, the reduced albumin-water partition coefficient
reported for HFPO–DA compared to PFHxA indicates that ether oxygen substitution may attenuate protein-binding
affinity, providing a plausible mechanism for the elevated BFTEs observed
for PFMOAA and PFO5DoDA.
In relation to health outcomes, this
study identified significant
positive associations between elevated concentrations of short-chain
PFCA and PFECA, particularly PFBA and PFPeA, and the likelihood of
DOR in reproductive-aged women. These associations corresponded with
declines in AMH levels and AFC. AMH, a glycoprotein hormone secreted
by granulosa cells of early stage follicles, regulates the recruitment
of primordial follicles and correlates with the number of growing
follicles. In AMH-knockout mouse models,
younger mice show accelerated recruitment of primordial follicles,
while older mice exhibit near-complete depletion of the follicle pool. This hormonal disruption leads to premature
follicular exhaustion and causes reduced AFC, eventually manifesting
as DOR. These mechanistic insights align
with retrospective data showing negative correlations between serum
PFBA and PFPeA levels and circulating AMH. Additional support comes from follicular fluid analyses in women
undergoing assisted reproduction, where higher PFAS mixtures are reported
to be inversely associated with AMH levels. Interestingly, positive correlations were observed between long-chain
PFCA/PFECA (PFOA) and PFSA/PFESA (PFHxS). This may reflect enhanced
primordial follicle recruitment, followed by accelerated follicular
depletion. In contrast, inverse associations
between DOR and PFTriDA, PFTeDA, and PFHxS were also observed. It
is necessary to emphasize that these associations do not represent
protective actions and may instead reflect residual confounding or
feedback mechanisms by which ovarian dysfunction alters PFAS metabolism,
tissue distribution, or excretion. One study observed that estradiol
could regulate the expression of transport proteins, facilitating
the entry of PFAS into urine and reducing the serum concentration
in ovariectomized female mice. This suggests
that hormonal fluctuations in DOR patients may influence the systemic
distribution and clearance of PFAS. Meanwhile, the median concentration
of PFHxS, PFTeDA and PFTriDA in this study was higher in the control
group than in the case group, which may explain the negative association
with DOR. Nonetheless, further studies are warranted to elucidate
these processes and clarify causality.
Given that human exposure
typically involves complex mixtures rather
than isolated PFAS compounds, this study applied both WQS and BKMR
to characterize mixed effects. WQS identified a significant positive
association between combined PFAS burden and DOR risk, with BKMR demonstrating
a consistent monotonic increase in DOR likelihood across the exposure
gradient. A study showed a positive association between PFAS mixtures
(PFOA, PFOS, PFHxA, PFDA, PFNA, PFUdA, PFTrDA, LPFHpS, and LPFHxS)
and DOR risk. Although the association
did not reach statistically significant, the short-chain compound
PFHxA exhibited a relatively high cPIP in BKMR model. Accumulating
mechanistic evidence indicates that PFAS mixtures may compromise ovarian
reserve through multiple interconnected pathways. Activation of peroxisome
proliferator-activated receptor signaling disrupts lipid homeostasis,
drives abnormal lipid accumulation, and
suppresses genes essential for oocyte maturation, collectively diminishing developmental competence. Disruption of gap-junction intercellular communication
between oocytes and granulosa cells further interferes with cytoplasmic
and metabolic coordination essential for oocyte maturation. Additional studies implicate mitochondrial dysfunction,
including inhibition of electron transport chain activity, impaired
ovarian oxidative phosphorylation, increased ROS generation, and induction
of granulosa cell necroptosis via intrinsic pathways, culminating
in follicular atresia and tissue injury.
,
These potential pathways likely operate synergistically to disrupt
oocyte development and maturation, deplete follicular reserves, and
ultimately elevate the risk of DOR in reproductive-aged women.
In response to increasing regulatory constraints on the production
and use of traditional long-chain PFAS, short-chain alternativescharacterized
by relatively short half-lives and low
bioaccumulation have been rapidly
adopted. However, a growing body of toxicological evidence indicates
that these replacements pose considerable reproductive risks. For
example, PFBS exposure in Caenorhabditis elegans has
been shown to induce germ cell apoptosis via ROS elevation, with prenatal exposure leading to reduction
of ovarian follicles and corpus luteum in adult offspring. In humans, gestational exposure to PFHxS and
PFPeA is associated with higher incidence of small-for-gestational-age
(SGA) neonates and accelerated placental senescence. Consistent with these findings, the present study identified
PFBA as a principal driver of increased DOR risk. Subchronic exposure
of PFBA in zebrafish induces oocyte deformation and follicular atresia
and disrupts estrogen homeostasis through direct and indirect targeting
of estrogen-related receptor γ at nanomolar concentrations. Simultaneously, high serum PFBA concentrations
also correlate with adverse reproductive outcomes, including unexplained
recurrent spontaneous abortion (URSA) and increased preterm birth risk. These
multidisciplinary data reinforce concerns that short-chain PFCA/PFECA,
particularly PFBA, may adversely impact female reproductive health.
PCR further delineated heterogeneous exposure-response relationships
across individual PFAS. After accounting for multicollinearity, two
distinct exposure patterns emerged. PC1 was characterized predominantly
by long-chain PFCA/PFECA and PFSA/PFESA (excluding PFBS), whereas
PC2 reflected short-chain PFCA/PFECA exposures (excluding PFHpA).
Notably, PC2 exhibited strong positive associations with DOR risk
and inverse correlations with both AMH and AFC, reinforcing the contribution
of short-chain PFCA/PFECA to diminished ovarian reserve after dimensionality
reduction analysis. Pearson correlation analysis indicates that PFBS
and PFHpA exhibit lower correlations with other PFAS (r = 0.06–0.29
and 0.09–0.20 respectively), suggesting that these compounds
have limited correlation between exposure sources and distribution
behavior. This finding also explains why PCA identifies them as distinct
drivers of PC3 and PC4.
To the best of our knowledge, this study
represents the first matched
case-control investigation to assess associations between DOR and
a comprehensive panel of legacy and emerging PFAS, analyzed both as
individual compounds and as mixtures. DOR was defined as a binary
clinical diagnosis rather than inferred from surrogate biomarkers,
enabling improved specificity in outcome classification. Follicular
fluid served as the biological matrix, offering a more direct representation
of ovarian exposure than serum or plasma. Furthermore, the robustness
of the mixed-effects results was confirmed through multiple models.
Importantly, both single-compound and mixture analyses identified
short-chain PFCA/PFECA as predominant contributors to PFAS accumulation
in follicular fluid and principal drivers of mixture effects, providing
novel human evidence of their potential reproductive toxicity. However,
several study limitations must be acknowledged. The cross-sectional
case-control design precludes causal inference, necessitating confirmation
through longitudinal and mechanistic studies. Sampling of follicular
fluid at a single time point also limits the ability to capture cumulative
or cyclical exposure variation. Notably, samples collected on one
side cannot represent the exposure on the other side. Although there
is no evidence indicating significant distribution differences of
PFAS between left and right ovaries, we cannot rule out variations
arising from disparities in the degree of local vascularization. Furthermore,
the study sample was recruited exclusively from a single reproductive
medical center in Shenyang, China, which may limit the generalizability
of the research results to other geographical regions, ethnic backgrounds,
or populations with different exposure characteristics. Shenyang,
as an industrial city in Northeast China, has a different PFAS exposure
profile from other regions. Meanwhile,
the participants recruited from the reproductive medicine center may
differ from the general population in seeking healthy behaviors, lifestyles,
or potential causes of infertility, which may introduce selection
bias. Although rigorous matching and multivariable adjustment were
implemented to control for key confounders, residual confounding cannot
be fully excluded. Finally, we need to acknowledge the limitation
of sample size. Therefore, future research should combine larger prospective
cohorts with toxicological studies to reveal the impact of short-chain
and alternative PFCA/PFECA on ovarian function.
Introduction
Per- and polyfluoroalkyl
substances (PFAS) constitute a diverse
group of synthetic chemicals extensively deployed across industrial
applications and consumer products since the mid-20th century, including
firefighting foams, food packaging, textiles, and leather treatment. Among them, perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA) and
perfluorooctanesulfonic acid (PFOS) are long-chain representatives
that have been persistently detected across environmental compartments.
Their widespread occurrence reflects high chemical stability and pronounced
bioaccumulation potential, and their toxicological
profiles include hepatotoxicity and immunotoxicity,
,
leading
to international regulatory actions. In
response to phase-out policies targeting legacy PFAS, the chemical
industry has increasingly adopted short-chain analogs and developed
structurally modified substitutes, including
perfluoroalkyl ether carboxylic acids (PFECA) and perfluoroalkyl ether
sulfonic acids (PFESA), which feature ether linkages or hydrogen/chlorine
atom substitutions within their backbones.
Despite these structural modifications, most alternatives
retain
environmental persistence and toxicity comparable to those of phased-out
legacy compounds and are now frequently detected in various environmental
matrices, including soils and surface
waters, as well as human biological fluids
such as serum and breast milk. Recent mechanistic studies have revealed that
exposure to short-chain compounds, such as perfluorobutanoic acid
(PFBA), can elicit more pronounced oxidative stress responses than
those triggered by PFOA, characterized by increased mitochondrial
reactive oxygen species (ROS) generation and robust suppression of
antioxidant enzyme activities in neuronal cells. Epidemiological findings have also connected prenatal exposure
to perfluorobutanesulfonic acid (PFBS) and perfluoroheptanoic acid
(PFHpA) with endocrine disruption, including changes in fetal gonadotropin
levels and aberrant free androgen regulation. Collectively, these findings underscore rising concerns over the
toxicological equivalency of PFAS alternatives and their potential
to exert adverse reproductive and developmental effects.
Infertility
has emerged as a significant global public health issue,
with prevalence estimates ranging from 12.6% to 17.5% and showing
a persistent upward trajectory.
,
Among the principal
contributors to female infertility is diminished ovarian reserve (DOR),
a condition marked by a progressive loss in both the quantity and
developmental competence of oocytes. DOR
is broadly categorized into physiological age-related decline and
premature pathological depletion, with
the latter drawing increasingly clinical focus due to its rising incidence
among young reproductive-aged women. Beyond
its role in reducing natural fecundity and increasing the risk of
recurrent pregnancy loss,
,
DOR is frequently linked
to adverse outcomes in in vitro fertilization (IVF)
cycles, including poor ovarian response and elevated risks of obstetric
and perinatal complications such as preeclampsia and fetal vascular
abnormalities. This trend underscores
the need to identify and characterize modifiable risk factors contributing
to early ovarian dysfunction.
In
parallel with established determinants such as chronological
age and genetic predisposition, environmental exposure to pollutants
has gained increasing recognition as a critical influence on ovarian
aging.
,
Among these, PFAS are a prominent class
of endocrine-disrupting chemicals associated with female reproductive
toxicity, specifically ovarian dysfunction and folliculogenesis.
,
Experimental models in mice have demonstrated that chronic PFOS
exposure leads to the reduction of histone H3K14 acetylation at the
promoter region of the steroidogenic acute regulatory (STAR) promoter,
thereby impairing estrogen biosynthesis and disrupting follicular
development and ovulation. Similarly,
PFOA has been shown to disrupt hormone levels and accelerate follicle
growth in a nonmonotonic manner through decreasing steroidogenic gene
expression. Epidemiological data further
support these mechanistic findings, indicating that elevated PFAS
body burdens correlate with altered ovarian reserve markers, including
reductions in anti-Müllerian hormone (AMH), lower antral follicle
counts (AFC), and altered follicle stimulating hormone (FSH) levels. Together, these findings implicate PFAS exposure
as a potential contributor to both the onset and progression of DOR.
Nevertheless, current investigations into the relationship between
PFAS exposure and DOR remain constrained by several methodological
and conceptual gaps. First, most existing studies have focused predominantly
on legacy PFAS, while the potential reproductive effects of emerging
alternatives have received limited attention. Second, reliance on
peripheral blood as the primary biological samples may not adequately
capture internal PFAS distributions relevant to ovarian physiology. In contrast, follicular fluidenriched
in plasma-derived constituents selectively transported across the
follicular barrierrepresents a more proximate and biologically
relevant matrix for assessing chemical exposures that may influence
oocyte maturation and folliculogenesis. PFAS have been detected in follicular fluid,
,
suggesting that these substances can cross the barrier and act locally
on developing gametes, thereby disturbing
ovarian function.
Given the reproductive consequences associated
with DOR, identifying
modifiable environmental determinants has become an urgent public
health objective. The present study was designed to address critical
gaps by (1) quantifying the transfer efficiencies of legacy and emerging
PFAS from plasma to follicular fluid based on paired concentration
measurements; (2) evaluating association between individual compounds
and PFAS mixtures in follicular fluid and the probability of DOR in
a case-control framework matched for age and body mass index (BMI);
and (3) investigating correlations between follicular PFAS levels
and key clinical indicators of ovarian reserve. By characterizing
chemical burdens within the local ovarian microenvironment, this study
provides mechanistic and epidemiological evidence linking PFAS exposure
to female reproductive dysfunction.
Text is read by the "Ask this paper" AI Q&A widget below.
Extraction quality varies by source — PMC NXML preserves structure
cleanly, OA-HTML may include some navigation residue, and OA-PDF can
have broken hyphenation. The publisher copy
(via DOI)
is the canonical version.