Full text
5,746 characters
· extracted from
oa-pdf
· click to expand
T
he Human Rights Challenge filed
Aug. 18 in Ontario by Amir
Attaran with Anna Ilha brought
national attention to discrimination
against socially disadvantaged Canadian
women/couples who are seeking clini-
cally appropriate care.
Ontario publicly funded in vitro fer-
tilization (IVF) from 1985 to April
Fool’s Day 1994,
1 when it was “delisted”
except for completely blocked fallopian
tubes. This delisting, foolish from a sci-
entific, clinical, social, ethical and even
economic perspective,
1-4 excluded most
Canadians with clinically appropriate
indications for IVF from having chil-
dren, including those with oocyte deple-
tion (common in cancer survivors and
women over 35), scarred fallopian tubes,
endometriosis and inadequate sperm.
These Canadians were also generally
excluded from being chosen by an
adopting-out birth mother (many of
whom may want a white picket fence)
3
and from international adoption (expen-
sive). With Ontario delisting IVF, other
provinces did not go forward with fund-
ing IVF.
Ten years after Ontario delisted IVF,
Canada’s Act Respecting Assisted Human
Reproduction and Related Researc h
became law. Although this act is similar
to legislation in Australia, Western
Europe and other countries in promoting
the safety of women undergoing assisted
reproduction and health of children born
thereof, Canada is alone in not funding
IVF.
3 Indeed, only 15% of Canadian
women with clinical indications access
IVF compared with countries that fund
IVF.
5 This Canadian policy may be dis-
criminatory in light of Section 2(E) of our
Act which states, “persons who seek to
undergo assisted human reproduction pro-
cedures must not be discriminated against
… including on the basis of sexual orien-
tation or marital status.”
3 The act’s use of
the word “including” suggests other
social factors are also not appropriate
bases for discrimination.
3
Ontario’s 1994 delisting of IVF was
based on misinterpretation of the Royal
Commission on Reproductive Technolo-
gies’ 1993 recommendation to “proceed
with care,” as well as a lack of understand-
ing of the financial repercussions of refus-
ing to fund IVF and insensitivity to the
experience of the many Canadians who
want to be a parent. The lack of under-
standing that allowed Ontario to “pro-
ceed” only for its wealthier citizens, and
not to “care” for its socially less advan-
taged citizens continues as reflected in
comments posted on the Globe and Mail’s
online discussion board the day following
its coverage of the Attaran human rights
challenge, including: blaming women
“over the age of 28” for delaying having
children (when social factors may force
women and men to delay), and worrying
that we would have to “pay a lot more in
taxes” (when, in fact, public funding of
IVF would benefit provincial coffers
1,3,4).
IVF, especially with single embryo
transfer, prevents the high-order multiple
pregnancies that result when women,
financially excluded from accessing IVF,
“choose” gonadotrophin fertility drugs.
These high-order multiple pregnancies
are associated with extreme premature
birth and huge costs of neonatal intensive
care and long-term support of surviving
children with cerebral palsy, blindness,
and cognitive and other impairments.
1,3,4
These costs were recognized in Quebec’s
recent decision to publicly fund IVF, and
in the Aug. 26, 2009 release of the
Ontario Expert Panel on Infertility and
Adoption Report.
According to clinician and researcher
Ed Hughes, the reasons why IVF has
remained unfunded for so long in
Canada, are that “sub-fertile Canadians
are largely invisible” and “poorly under-
stood,” and the medical profession has
not lobbied for IVF funding, as noted in
the Nova Scotia Supreme Court decision
against public funding of IVF.
4
The success of Terry Buffett’s 2006
human rights challenge, resulting in the
Canadian Armed Forces paying for his
wife’s IVF cycles and amending its pol-
icy regarding IVF funding, suggests clini-
cally appropriate care may indeed be a
human right in Canada. If the Attaran
human rights challenge is successful, all
provinces may not only be forced to end
their discrimination against socially disad-
vantaged Canadians who want clinically
appropriate infertility treatment, but also
to stop the creeping discrimination of
two-tiered medicine, including access to
more expensive, but more effective new
clinical strategies.
Jeff Nisker MD PhD
Professor of Obstetrics and
Gynaecology and Oncology
Schulich School of Medicine and
Dentistry
The University of Western Ontario
London, Ont.
REFERENCES
1. Nisker JA. Anniversary of injustice: April fool's day,
1994. Will the enactment of Bill C-6 be the birthday
of equitable reproductive health care in Canada. J
Obstet Gynaecol Can2004;26:321-4.
2. Hughes EG, Beecroft ML, Wilkie V, et al. A multi-
centre randomized controlled trial of expectant man-
agement versus IVF in women with Fallopian tube
patency. Hum Reprod2004;19:1105-9.
3. Nisker J. Distributive justice and infertility treatment in
Canada.J Obstet Gynaecol Can2008;30: 425-31.
4. Hughes E. Access to effective fertility care in Canada.
J Obstet Gynaecol Can2008;30: 389-93.
5. Collins J. An international survey of the health eco-
nomics of IVF and ICSI. Hum Reprod Update
2002;8:265-77.
Salon CMAJ
All editorial matter in CMAJ represents the opinions of the authors and not necessarily those of the Can adian Medical Association.
CMAJ NOVEMBER 10, 2009 181(10)
© 2009 Canadian Medical Association or its licensors
764
DOI:10.1503/cmaj.091620
Cynthia O’Brien’s clay sculpture, “Emer-
gence One” (2009), represents a sperm.
Cynthia O’Brien
Socially based discrimination against clinically appropriate care
A longer version of this article was
published at cmaj.ca
Text is read by the "Ask this paper" AI Q&A widget below.
Extraction quality varies by source — PMC NXML preserves structure
cleanly, OA-HTML may include some navigation residue, and OA-PDF can
have broken hyphenation. The publisher copy
(via DOI)
is the canonical version.