Development of a Synthetic Hydrogel to Foster Microvascularization of an Endometriosis Microphysiological System

other OA: hybrid CC-BY-4.0

Abstract

The ascent of novel alternative methods in drug development spotlights the dual needs for improved biological fidelity to in vivo, along with reproducibility, especially in regulatory applications. The need for pre-clinical models of patient-derived endometriosis lesions motivates the development of a vascularizable, completely synthetic extracellular matrix (v-CS-ECM) that supports morphogenesis of perfusable microvasculature in a microfluidic device, in the context of relevant lesion cells. This paper describes v-CS-ECM, a peptide-modified polyethylene glycol-based hydrogel crosslinked with a cell-degradable peptide that achieves these dual goals. Vessels form by morphogenesis after the liquid v-CS-ECM precursor, containing endothelial cells and fibroblasts, is injected into the tissue compartment to encapsulate cells. Vessel formation is influenced by ECM biochemical and biophysical properties, the source of vascular cells, and microphysiological system operating conditions. The v-CS-ECM also supports the co-culture of endometrial epithelial organoids and fibroblasts, and formation of microvascularized endometriosis lesion-like structures when all cell types are co-encapsulated in a microfluidic device with constant flow. Hence, v-CS-ECM has the potential to improve preclinical evaluation of endometriosis drug efficacy by enabling microvascularized patient-derived lesion models.
Full text 71,485 characters · extracted from oa-doi-fallback · 2 sections · click to expand

Abstract

The ascent of novel alternative methods in drug development spotlights the dual needs for improved biological fidelity to in vivo, along with reproducibility, especially in regulatory applications. The need for pre-clinical models of patient-derived endometriosis lesions motivates the development of a vascularizable, completely synthetic extracellular matrix (v-CS-ECM) that supports morphogenesis of perfusable microvasculature in a microfluidic device, in the context of relevant lesion cells. This paper describes v-CS-ECM, a peptide-modified polyethylene glycol-based hydrogel crosslinked with a cell-degradable peptide that achieves these dual goals. Vessels form by morphogenesis after the liquid v-CS-ECM precursor, containing endothelial cells and fibroblasts, is injected into the tissue compartment to encapsulate cells. Vessel formation is influenced by ECM biochemical and biophysical properties, the source of vascular cells, and microphysiological system operating conditions. The v-CS-ECM also supports the co-culture of endometrial epithelial organoids and fibroblasts, and formation of microvascularized endometriosis lesion-like structures when all cell types are co-encapsulated in a microfluidic device with constant flow. Hence, v-CS-ECM has the potential to improve preclinical evaluation of endometriosis drug efficacy by enabling microvascularized patient-derived lesion models. 1 Introduction Microphysiological systems that capture human physiological processes are emerging as favorable alternatives to animal models in efforts to study disease and develop therapies. Incorporation of perfusable microvasculature is essential for many applications, as capillary endothelia and pericytes not only control the transport of oxygen, metabolites, and therapeutics, they engage in local paracrine signaling of tissue homeostasis and perturbation response, and gate immune cell trafficking [1, 2]. These capabilities make microphysiological systems especially well-suited for modeling gynecologic disorders (e.g., endometriosis, adenomyosis, heavy menstrual bleeding), which have been historically understudied in part due to the shortcomings of animal models in recapitulating human tissue dynamics mediated by complex interplay between hormones, immune cells, and vasculature [3]. Endometriosis is a debilitating gynecological disorder that afflicts ∼10% of women and girls [4, 5]. Endometriosis lesions are defined as ectopic growth of endometrial-like tissue comprising endometrial epithelia and CD10+ stroma, typically comprising a polarized epithelial monolayer surrounding a fluid-filled lumen, supported by vasculature, nerves, and immune cell infiltrate [6]. As endothelial-fibroblast-epithelial interactions are crucially intertwined in determining how endometrial cells respond to changing hormone levels throughout the menstrual cycle [7-9], an in vitro model system that captures these microvascular interactions, together with a perfusable vasculature to enable immune cell trafficking in long-term (weeks) culture, is highly desirable for analyzing patient-specific disease features and testing therapeutics. Developing such a model requires an extracellular matrix (ECM) that simultaneously supports microvascular morphogenesis and function, endometrial epithelial organoid growth, and immune cell incorporation and trafficking, along with tissue remodeling of the ECM. While natural ECMs are now commonly used for the individual phenomena—fibrin for vascular morphogenesis and Matrigel for epithelial organoids—these are not sufficient for the integrated lesion model. An accessible and now widely-used approach to creating perfusable microvasculature involves morphogenesis of vessels from vascular cells seeded into the tissue chamber of a microfluidic device in a process that embeds them in a supporting extracellular matrix [10-13] (Figure 1). The morphogenesis process is typically initiated by mixing endothelial cells with supporting cells (e.g., fibroblasts/pericytes) in an ECM precursor solution (e.g., fibrin, collagen) before seeding into the central channel of a microfluidic device, where flanking side channels are filled with culture media. Over the course of 5–7 days, endothelial cells form network structures that morph into open-lumen microvessels with surrounding pericyte-like cells, capturing architectural features of native blood vessels [1, 12, 14, 15]. Flow is commonly induced by gravity, using rocking, or reservoirs with different media heights. Microfluidic chips for this purpose are commonly fabricated from polydimethyl siloxane (PDMS) due to its ease of prototyping and favorable imaging and oxygen transport properties. However, PDMS avidly absorbs lipophilic compounds such as estradiol, confounding efforts to control steroid hormone levels in gynecology models or test lipophilic drugs such as kinase inhibitors. Although more challenging to prototype (but ultimately amenable to large scale production), chips made from thermoplastic materials resist the absorption of lipophilic compounds, hence such hard plastic chips are emerging as standards in practical applications in drug development [11, 16, 17]. Microvascular morphogenesis protocols rely heavily on fibrin, which serves as a provisional wound-healing ECM in vivo. As the expectations for reproducibility and biological performance of MPS continue to rise, the shortcomings of fibrin—including lot-to-lot variability, undesirable biochemical cues, limited modularity, and poorly-controlled degradation [18-20] – are becoming increasingly apparent. These shortcomings are accentuated in applications that incorporate additional cell types to create functional tissue mimics, as fibrin may impair or otherwise not support biological functions. For example, human mucosal epithelia, such as gut and endometrium, are expanded and cultured as organoids in basement membrane-mimicking Matrigel, which shares many of fibrin's performance limitations but offers a complex mix of biological cues that support epithelia [21-23]. While a combination of fibrin and Matrigel enables a limited vascularization of gut organoids [24], a more reproducible and biologically versatile ECM for creating complex microvascularized tissues is arguably desirable for MPS translation into the drug development pipeline. However, no completely synthetic extracellular matrix (CS-ECM) for vessel formation by morphogenesis in vitro has yet been reported [10-12]. Building on design principles we developed for creating a peptide-modified polyethylene glycol CS-ECM that supports endothelial network formation [19, 25] and endometrial epithelial-stromal co-cultures [26, 27], we recently described a CS-ECM formulation that is suitable for expansion and culture of primary patient-derived human epithelial gut, endometrial, and pancreatic organoids [28-30]. Beyond organoid monoculture, this supports co-culture of these organoids with stromal and immune cells [29, 30] in static (droplet) culture, where the organoids may stay entirely encapsulated or expand in size to emerge from the gel, forming a mucosal barrier along the surface of the CS-ECM [29]. Importantly, this CS-ECM overcomes the rapid degradation associated with Matrigel and allows long-term studies with relevant tissue densities [29]. The CS-ECM incorporates both synthetic peptides that bind to adhesion receptors known to be expressed by the target cells, as well as peptides that bind to native ECM produced by each cell type in the culture, so that the cell-specific ECM is sequestered in the cell microenvironment [27, 30]. This CS-ECM is crosslinked with matrix metalloproteinase (MMP)-susceptible peptides, enabling local cell-mediated remodeling. As with other synthetic or semi-synthetic ECM approaches [31], the modularity of this organoid-supporting CS-ECM enables its properties to be tailored across a wide spectrum of biophysical, degradation, and compositional property ranges to mimic features of disease or control tissues and to support a wide range of co-cultured cell types [28-30]. Here, inspired by the pressing need for humanized models of endometriosis lesions, we report the design and function of the first CS-ECM that supports the morphogenesis of perfusable microvascular networks in microfluidic devices, and demonstrate this formulation is compatible with expansion and culture of endometrial epithelia and stroma, and with creation of lesion-like structures surrounded by microvasculature. The design approach and testing paradigm for this new “vascularizable” CS-ECM (termed here “v-CS-ECM”) (Figure 1A) is guided by a semi-empirical screen of hydrogel and cellular parameters starting with those governing interconnected endothelial network formation in static microfluidic culture (Figure 1B,C). Following analysis of outcomes in static culture, we introduce continuous fluid flow, systematically varying parameters to achieve perfusable lumenized endothelial network structures, termed microvessels. Finally, we demonstrate this hydrogel supports microvessel formation in co-culture with human endometrial epithelial patient-derived organoids and macrophages, thus establishing the foundation for modeling endometriosis and illustrating potential for modeling other chronic inflammatory diseases. 2 Results 2.1 Semi-Empirical Screen of Cell and Hydrogel Parameters Impacting Vascular Network Formation in Static Culture 2.1.1 Introduction to Screen and Description of Microfluidic Device We used a semi-empirical screen of various hydrogel, cellular, device and tissue bed parameters to define conditions associated with morphogenesis of perfusable microvessels in the modified CS-ECM hydrogel we call here v-CS-ECM (Figure 1C). We first screened the spectrum of conditions for ability to induce morphogenesis after 5 days of culture in microfluidic chips using standard microvascular cell sources (HUVEC and NHLF) in the absence of flow (static condition), using morphologic metrics of vessel diameter and fraction of covered area as previously described [10, 32] to identify conditions that would be most likely to result in lumenized, perfusable vessels and thus most suitable for more resource-intensive perfusion experiments. Apparent lumenization of networks in static culture does not always result in robust permeability, due to failure of vessels to open at the monolayer formed along fluid-tissue interface along the media channels without influence of mechanical forces to drive interstitial flow [33, 34], which also stabilizes vessels after formation [32]. We therefore conducted a second round of screens using the most favorable “lumenized” conditions from static culture, using peristaltic pumps to drive recirculating flow and a trans-tissue pressure drop during morphogenesis to accomplish perfusion of lumenized vessels (see Section 2.2). While microvascular phenotypes are well-known to be tissue-specific [35], practical issues of accessibility (including of cells already labeled with fluorescent reporters) and wide-spread use in other angiogenesis assays, contributed to the adoption of human umbilical vein endothelial cells (HUVECs) combined with normal human lung fibroblasts (NHLFs) as a workhorse model system for self-assembled microvessel formation [1, 10, 12, 36]. As our ultimate goal is to develop protocols that can readily be adapted to a range of microvascular cell sources, we implemented a strategy of using HUVEC/NHLF in initial studies in screens as a benchmark against established work in the field, then extending the protocols to microvasculature cells relevant for endometriosis lesions. Based on previous protocols described for vascular morphogenesis in microfluidic devices [10, 37, 38], we designed and fabricated a custom device that could accommodate the anticipated relatively large size of a growing endometriosis lesion, with a vascular bed 1.8 mm in width and 0.45 mm in height (see detailed dimensions in Figure S1; for reference, commercial AIM Biotech chips are 1.3 mm wide and 0.25 mm height). Four microposts on each side of the central gel channel pin the liquid hydrogel precursor solution via surface tension during loading. The chips were fabricated from PDMS, with appropriate pre-saturation with hormones (Figure S14) once endometrial cells were incorporated. 2.1.2 Hydrogel Composition and Biophysical Parameters We reasoned that strategic modification of our CS-ECM [29] to include endothelial-targeted peptides, along with possible modulation of biophysical properties, would lead to a v-CS-ECM supportive of perfusable vasculature while retaining features supporting epithelial, stromal, and immune cell co-culture, which are desirable for modeling endometriosis and adenomyosis lesions. In a previous semi-empirical screen of factors influencing endothelial cell network formation in PEG-based CS-ECM, we found that endothelial cells favor soft matrices [19]. However, an additional constraint is gel swelling post-crosslinking, as formulations that support network formation in free-swelling gels with large swelling coefficients may fail to support network formation in microfluidic devices, where swelling is constrained [19]. Therefore, combining these considerations, we aimed for a softer gel with a smaller swelling factor compared to the canonical regime used for organoids [29] by decreasing the weight percent of 8-arm polyethylene glycol and increasing the crosslinking ratio, respectively. Additionally, we have previously determined threshold concentrations of adhesion and matrix-targeting peptides required to support robust organoid and stromal co-culture (1.5 mM PHSRN-K-RGD, 1.5 mM GFOGER, 0.5 mM Basement Membrane Binder, 0.5 mM Fibronectin Binder) [28, 29], hence kept these constant while adding a peptide targeted to endothelial interactions. Laminin, an ECM protein, is an abundant component of the basement membrane in blood vessels [39, 40]. Endothelial cells cultured in collagen hydrogels supplemented with laminin exhibit greater end-to-end endothelial network formation and increased VEGF uptake, compared to endothelial cells cultured in collagen alone [41]. Short adhesive peptides derived from laminin, including IKVAV from the laminin α1 chain and YIGSR from the laminin β1 chain are attractive candidates for creating v-CS-ECM [42-44]. YIGSR has been shown to regulate endothelial cell morphology in synthetic matrices, and when combined with RGD peptides, increases endothelial cell migration rates and endothelial tube length in vitro [40, 42, 43, 45]. Given that we wanted to maintain the adhesion and matrix-targeting peptides developed for organoid culture, including RGD, we chose to incorporate YIGSR instead of IKVAV, as the combination of YIGSR and RGD in PEG hydrogels has been shown to form more stable endothelial tubule networks with increased tubule length and diameter compared to PEG hydrogels functionalized with a combination of IKVAV and RGD [42]. As a starting point, we compared a softer hydrogel formulation (3.0wt.% PEG, 0.52 thiol-ene crosslinking ratio) to a previous formulation used for organoids (3.6wt.% PEG, 0.43 thiol-ene crosslinking ratio). These initial experiments to screen hydrogel composition and biophysical parameters were performed with a total cell concentration of 12 x 106/mL (7:1 HUVEC:NHLF), based on the upper end of the range of optimal results reported in fibrin. We used network area fraction, determined by a MATLAB-based network quantification pipeline [46] of day 5 images (Methods) as a metric that captures significant differences between formulations, as network metrics can be reasonable predictors of later success in forming lumenized, perfusable vessels. We found that this new formulation slightly increased the network area fraction in HUVEC/NHLF seeded into devices (from 0.30 to 0.34; Figure 2A). This formulation demonstrated a storage modulus of ∼160 Pa and a swelling factor of ∼1.5 (approximately 25% softer, and with 30% less swelling compared to the previous organoid formulation [29], Figure S2). Additionally, when we added YIGSR (0.6 mM), while maintaining the concentrations of the four other peptides in the canonical CS-ECM constant, we found a significant increase in area fraction of endothelial cells compared to the previous organoid formulation [29] (from 0.30 to 0.38, p<0.05; Figure 2A). Importantly, the addition of YIGSR did not change the hydrogel mass swelling factor or bulk stiffness assessed via rheology (Figure S2), indicating this increase in endothelial area fraction can likely be attributed to the peptide addition and not other hydrogel parameters. 2.1.3 Cell Parameters For the HUVEC/NHLF combination in fibrin, both formation of connected microvessel networks and ultimately perfusable microvessels depends on both the absolute and relative endothelial cell and stromal cell concentrations [10]. Networks formed in the optimal v-CS-ECM formulation described above were not perfusable, with a standard dextran perfusion assay initiated via gravity driven flow after 7 days of static culture (Figure S3B). We therefore speculated that (i) the diameter of vessels formed was too low (<25 µm) to support perfusion and immune cell circulation and (ii) morphogenesis in v-CS-ECM over the same time scale may require a greater number of endothelial cells compared to the standard concentration range (5–12 M HUVECs/mL) needed for fibrin [10, 47]. To that end, we performed a semi-empirical parameter screen with 12–18 M HUVECs/mL and ratios of 5:1, 7:1, and 10:1 endothelial to fibroblast cells. We determined that 18 M HUVECs/mL with a 7:1 HUVEC:NHLF ratio resulted in the greatest area fraction in static culture conditions and used that combination for the remainder of studies involving HUVEC-NHLF cocultures (Figure 2B,C). Notably, when using this optimized concentration and ratio, the v-CS-ECM formulation significantly increased the area fraction of endothelial cells compared to both the softer CS-ECM (0.45 to 0.52, p<0.05) and organoid formulation [29] (0.35 to 0.52, p<0.0001) (Figure 2D; Figure S3A). This condition formed interconnected networks with an area fraction of ∼0.5 and a mean network diameter approximately 35 µm; however, despite significant network interconnectivity, which is an important first step toward creating vessel-like structures, these networks still did not have open-lumen structures necessary to enable perfusion (Figure S3B). We therefore reasoned that, as in vivo, fluid flow factors may play a crucial role in the development of fully lumenized, perfusable vessels. 2.2 Introducing Flow and a Pressure Drop Results in Perfusable Vasculature Vessels in vivo are constantly exposed to hemodynamic forces, which influence their remodeling and functions [18, 48]. Many investigators use gravity-driven pressure gradients generated by a height difference in media reservoirs feeding the side channels [49]. Here, to avoid flow transients associated with gradual equilibration of reservoir heights, we adapted the static culture device to configurations incorporating recirculating peristaltic pump-driven flow through the side channels, using the return channel loop to generate defined weak or strong pressure drops across the tissue compartment, as either a simple loop or a serpentine return (Figure 3A; Figure S4). In these flow setups, the flow rate was controlled at 1µL/s, imposing a shear stress on the hydrogel walls of approximately 0.004 Pa according to COMSOL modeling simulations (see Methods, Figure S5 and Table S2). Importantly, all three device designs (static, simple-loop, serpentine-loop) have the same tissue chamber geometry and dimensions (Figure 3A, detailed dimensions in Figure S1), isolating continuous flow and pressure difference as the only variables. In the first configuration, we used a simple loop generating a very small (0.2 mm H2O) ΔP (Figure 3A; Figure S5), as this would emphasize the imposition of shear rather than transmural flow. After culturing for 7 days, vessels near the inlet and outlet gel-injection ports displayed open lumens and were perfusable as assessed via the flow of microbeads (Figure 3C), though networks near the center of the device did not become perfusable. We hypothesized that a more significant pressure drop across the channel may increase the fraction of perfusable vessels, as the biophysical forces imposed by pressure drops influence endothelial cell physiology [50, 51] and are commonly implemented in vascularized microphysiological systems [49]. To increase the ΔP in the context of a constant imposed recirculating flow, we implemented a serpentine looped channel design (Figure 3A). We measured the trans-tissue-channel ΔP as approximately 25 mm H2O (Figure S4) close to the value of 32 mm H2O predicted by a COMSOL model (Figure S5 and Table S2). Notably, when we cultured microvessel networks using the serpentine device exposed to flow throughout the entire duration of the experiment, we observed perfusable vessels, evidenced by the flow of fluorescent microbeads through open-lumen structures across the channel (Figure 3D; Figure S6 and Video S1). The vessels were open in ∼47% of the length of the device (Figure 3D; Figure S7), with most perfusable vessels in the top quarter and bottom quarter of the device, where top and bottom refer to regions of the tissue compartment near the inlets and outlets according to the orientation of the device depicted in Figure 4A. Additionally, these microvessels could be maintained in culture for at least 14 days under continuous flow (Figure S8), with relatively stable microvessel network morphology after 6–7 days of morphogenesis. As an attempt to decrease the high concentration of endothelial cells required, we tested 15 M HUVECs/mL (7:1 HUVEC:NHLF ratio) and observed perfusable vessels in the bottom quarter of the device (Figure S9A), indicating a partial success, and there are likely other parameters that could be optimized to decrease the endothelial cell density. Additionally, we screened the softer formulation without YIGSR using 18 M HUVECs/mL (7:1 HUVEC:NHLF ratio) and observed minimal perfusability (Figure S9B), indicating static experiments can be a valuable starting point for screening network formation with different parameters before moving to complex pumped experiments, which are lower throughput. While further iteration on parameters such as side channel geometry (influences shear stress on surface endothelia) and post placement (influences tissue biomechanics via its effects on gel compression and on durotaxis) is needed to reach 100% perfusable vessels across the entire channel, the current findings are a significant advance in the development of a completely synthetic hydrogel for microvascular morphogenesis. We did not pursue further iterations with HUVEC/NHLF co-cultures at this point as applications, such as the endometriosis lesion model we aspire to, involve different sources of vascular cells, and additional cell types, both of which will likely influence remodeling and vessel maturation. We therefore proceeded to investigate both underlying mechanistic hypotheses for differences in performance in these configurations, as well as new phenomenology that might arise from inclusion of endometrial epithelial organoids and immune cells, and use of uterine-derived vascular cells. 2.3 ECM Remodeling Contributes to Perfusable Vessel Formation MMP-mediated ECM remodeling is one potential flow-induced mechanism contributing to open lumen formation in our synthetic hydrogel between static and continuous flow conditions. MMP-2 has been shown to facilitate vessel formation in fibrin hydrogels [52], and the MMP-sensitive crosslinker in v-CS-ECM is susceptible to degradation via MMP-2. We therefore measured MMP-2 concentrations via ELISA on media samples collected after 24 h of circulation, at the time of daily media changes, throughout the time course of the morphogenesis process (days 1, 3, 5, and 7). Significantly greater MMP-2 levels were detected via ELISA in the spent medium from networks cultured in serpentine-loop devices with continuous flow compared to networks cultured in static conditions (Figure 4D). The MMP-2 levels were significantly higher at days 3 (pumped = 13.8 ng, static = 6.9 ng, p = 0.012) and 5 (pumped = 16.5 ng, static = 6.3 ng, p<0.0001) in the pumped condition compared to static and started to decrease at day 7 in both conditions. This increase in MMP-2 levels until day 5 coincides with the time period when open lumens emerge (between day 5 and day 7; Figure 4A; Figure S6), and the greater value in the pumped case correlates with greater degrees of perfusable microvessels in pumped vs static; hence, MMP-2 may contribute to remodeling leading to lumenization. Further validation of the role of MMP-2 in microvessel evolution requires selective inhibition of MMP-2, as has previously been done in fibrin hydrogels [52], we deferred additional mechanistic investigation in favor of experiments probing phenomenological outcomes of using different cell types to create an endometriosis lesion model. Unexpectedly, we did not observe a discernible difference in network diameter between static and serpentine-looped pumped devices (35 µm for both static and pumped conditions, Figure 4B), demonstrating an increased vessel diameter did not always enable perfusable microvessels. However, lack of observable perfusion does not necessarily mean that vessels lack lumens; lumenized vessels may fail to open up to the side channels. Lumenization can be assessed in multiple ways and is typically definitively assessed using electron microscopy or histological approaches, though is at times inferred using brightfield imaging. As our goal is not just lumenization, but perfusability, we used bead trafficking to assess perfusion (which requires open lumens) and correlated features on brightfield images corresponding to open lumens (Figure S6). The pumped devices fostered simpler network structures, evidenced by significantly fewer branch points (Figure 4C, static = 72, pumped = 50, p < 0.01), which has been similarly observed for HUVEC-NHLF cultures in fibrin hydrogels [48, 53]. 2.4 Successful Incorporation of Macrophages into Endothelial Networks While the bedrock of microvascular engineering focuses on co-culture of endothelial cells with a fibroblast population, macrophages are also key regulators of vascular networks. Macrophages are phenotypically plastic innate immune cells ubiquitous to tissue microenvironments, where they perform tissue homeostatic functions, including lipid and iron processing, along with wound-healing and immune defense against pathogens [54, 55]. Importantly, macrophages drive vessel sprouting, serve as sources of angiogenic growth factors, and are observed to align with nascent vasculature similar to support cells [56]. The homeostatic tissue-resident macrophage population is further augmented by trafficking of circulating CD14+ monocytes through the vasculature, driven by chemokine cues such as CCL2 [54, 55], contributing further to inflammatory cascades that influence vessel and tissue function [57, 58]. Given that macrophages are primary drivers of endometriosis lesion pathophysiology and a key therapeutic target [5, 59-61], we investigated protocols for their integration into our vascularized MPS, which would be beneficial for endometriosis lesion modeling and related inflammatory disorders. To generate macrophages, CD14+ human monocytes were isolated from healthy donors and differentiated over 6 days using 50 ng/mL macrophage-colony stimulating factor. We implemented the static culture screen (described above, and Methods), starting with keeping a constant concentration of HUVECs at 18 M/mL, while varying the concentration of macrophages in the supporting cell population (macrophages, NHLFs) from 0% to 100%, keeping the ratio of endothelial: supporting cells at 7:1 and the total concentration of supporting cells at 2.57 M/mL (Figure 5A). As the percentage of macrophages increased from 0% to 100% the endothelial network diameter, area fraction, and length density decreased (Figure 5B). Cultures entirely lacking NHLF (100% macrophage in supporting cell population) exhibited scattered network fragments but did not generate fully formed networks. The 9:1 and 6:1 fibroblast: macrophage ratios supported endothelial network diameter and area fraction values comparable to controls with no macrophages. In day 5 imaging (Figure 5A), macrophages appeared to have heterogeneous spreading morphologies with clear projections, an observation corroborated by Moore et al., who previously showed that macrophage morphology is highly spread in endothelial-macrophage co-cultures in a polyethylene glycol-based hydrogel [62]. To assess the functionality of macrophages in our system, we analyzed media supernatants for MMP-9, a major MMP produced by human macrophages that is known to have an influence on angiogenesis [51, 63, 64]. The amount of MMP-9 secreted corresponded with the number of macrophages in the culture, and was highest at day 1, with no detectable MMP-9 in the HUVEC-NHLF only condition (Figure 5C). We cannot confirm all MMP-9 is due to direct production by macrophages compared to indirect effects of macrophage cytokines on MMP-9 production without further investigation, because inflamed endothelia can produce relatively modest amounts of MMP-9 [65]. However, this dose-dependent MMP-9 secretion, only observed with macrophages indicates a difference in remodeling compared to the HUVEC-NHLF networks. The endothelial network morphology and MMP-9 trends were repeated with a second macrophage donor, giving us confidence macrophages maintain functionality in the v-CS-ECM (Figure S10). We similarly analyzed MMP-2 and did not see a clear trend with the presence of macrophages, except the macrophage only condition had the lowest total secreted enzyme (Figure 5D). Once we established that macrophages could be incorporated into microvascular networks, we confirmed the ability to form perfusable vessels with the 6:1 macrophage ratio. Similar to the HUVEC-NHLF only networks, perfusable networks formed in the serpentine loop devices under continuous flow, as evidenced by beads trafficking through the networks (Figure 5E) and likewise observed the significant increase in MMP-2 secretion when comparing static to pumped culture (Figure S11). We observe close proximity between the macrophages and vessels, likely indicating the macrophages are serving in a supporting cell capacity as previously reported in the literature [56, 66], though further studies are needed to confirm this conjecture. Together, this model provides a launch point to study the influence of innate immune cell behavior on vascular networks in a disease-specific context and demonstrates the ability of the v-CS-ECM hydrogel to support macrophages, which are an important pathological feature in the endometriosis lesion microenvironment. 2.5 Uterine Microvascular Endothelial Cells form Perfusable Vessels in v-CS-ECM While HUVECS and NHLFs are a useful system to benchmark vascular morphogenesis, vascular phenotypes vary significantly between tissues [35, 50, 67, 68], prompting us to evaluate how well protocols for the benchmark cell types can be extended to microvasculature relevant for a disease-specific model. Adenomyosis is a sibling disease of endometriosis, characterized by endometriosis-like lesions in the myometrium of the uterus. Noting that the fibroblasts in lesions have characteristics of endometrial stromal cells [69], we purchased commercial uterine microvessel endothelial cells (HUTMVECs), and combined them with primary patient-derived endometrial stromal cells as a model for microvasculature in the vicinity of an adenomyosis lesion. In similar fashion to our initial cell parameter screen with HUVEC and NHLF cell concentrations and ratios (Figure 2B,C), we performed a parameter screen with varying concentrations of endothelial and stromal cells. We again found 18 M HUTMVECs/mL and a ratio of 7:1 to result in the greatest network area fraction (0.41) and diameter (31 µm) (Figure 6A–C). When exposing these cultures to continuous flow using a serpentine-loop device, vessel structures were perfusable as evidenced by beads trafficking through the open lumens across the device (Figure 6D). Strikingly, the average vessel diameter was significantly increased without a change in network complexity (36 µm, Figure 6E,F) upon the transition from static culture to continuous flow conditions, as has been observed previously for generic vasculature formed with HUVECS/NHLFs in addition to brain-specific microvasculature in fibrin hydrogels [18, 48, 53, 70]. This observation is in contrast to the HUVEC/NHLF case, where the transition from network features observed in static to flow was limited to simpler network structures, without a significant change in vessel diameter (Figure 4B,C). Mirroring previous observations there is a significant increase in MMP-2 detected in the spent media from flow conditions compared to static culture (Figure 6G), however the relative levels of MMP-2 are much lower for the uterine microvessel cell source than from HUVEC/NHLF. Additionally, there is a continuous increase in MMP-2 throughout the course of a weeklong culture, potentially pointing toward the slightly slower network formation observed via daily imaging with these cells compared to HUVEC-NHLF coculture. These results were repeated with a second endometrial stromal cell donor with no significant changes in outcomes (Figure S12). 2.6 Co-Culture of Endometrial Epithelial Organoids With Uterine Microvascular Networks Endometriosis lesions are defined as ectopic growth of endometrial-like tissue, typically comprising a polarized epithelial monolayer surrounding a fluid-filled lumen with surrounding CD10+ stroma, supported by vasculature and immune cells [69, 71] (Figure 7A). After demonstrating that the v-CS-ECM can support self-assembly of perfusable vessels formed with uterine-derived endothelial cells and endometrial stromal cells (Figure 6), we investigated creation of an endometriosis lesion model by adding patient-derived endometrial epithelial organoids to the cell population at the time of culture initiation. Prior to combining vasculature and organoids, we first assessed primary patient-derived endometrial epithelial organoid emergence from single cells encapsulated in v-CS-ECM using hydrogel droplet culture (Figure 7B). Similar to the canonical CS-ECM we previously described for endometrial epithelial organoid culture [29], the v-CS-ECM supports robust organoid emergence from single cells (Figure 7C). As a consideration before combining all cell types relevant for co-culture in the full lesion model, a suitable mixed media formulation was developed to support both the endometrial epithelial organoids and vasculature. A 50-50 mixture of standard microvascular endothelial media was mixed with our organoid media [29], excluding the TGFβ inhibitor A8301 and Rock inhibitor Y-27632. This media was shown to support network formation in static culture to a comparable extent to standard endothelial cell media (Figure S13). Additionally, endometrial epithelial organoids are typically cultured in an estradiol (E2) containing medium, which is rapidly absorbed into PDMS. To mitigate this, we developed a presoaking method to saturate the PDMS with estradiol and maintain the desired concentration over the duration of the experiment (Figure S14). We note that for conditions simulating a full menstrual cycle, where hormone concentrations must be cycled, PDMS devices offer formidable challenges and use of relatively non-absorptive thermoplastics is desirable. Having established that v-CS-ECM supports endometrial epithelial organoid expansion, patient-derived organoids approximately 100 µm in diameter were combined with patient-matched endometrial stromal cells and commercially sourced uterine endothelial cells into the hydrogel precursor solution (Figure 7D), then injected into a serpentine-looped microfluidic device connected to continuous flow. Over the course of approximately a week, the organoids grew significantly in size (with ∼1.7 fold change increases in diameter, Figure S15 D) as expected in an estradiol-containing medium, while the microvessels self-assembled similar to previous experiments (Figure 7E; Figure S15 and Video S2). We anticipate that different donors may have different growth profiles based on observations we have seen with organoid culture, and future more in-depth studies could look at donor-specific lesion modeling. This demonstrates the v-CS-ECM and microfluidic device developed in this manuscript can support the coculture of epithelial, stromal, and endothelial cells. Notably, this system enables the formation of lesion-like structures and mirrors an important structural features of in vivo lesions, where vessels do not penetrate the lumens of endometriosis lesions but instead surround the fluid-filled epithelial monolayer structures, modeled by epithelial organoids in this system [69]. Notably, the microvessels did not have a significant change in diameter compared to microvessels generated without organoids in regions imaged without organoids (Figure S15C). Therefore, our model is physiologically appropriate when it excludes vessels from within the center of the lesion and has them surrounding the lesion (Figure S15A,B). While the results shown here are a proof-of-principle experiment showing that this v-CS-ECM enables the growth of lesion-like structures in the microfluidic devices, more in-depth experiments are required to create lesions with fibrotic and other features of in vivo lesions, and this model system is poised for further adaptation to specific questions about endometriosis lesion behavior, and ultimately to test novel drug compounds. 3 Discussion A substantial literature describes the use of fibrin and collagen hydrogels to create self-assembled vasculature, enabling foundational studies on vessel biology. Despite significant efforts toward creating self- assembled microvascular networks in synthetic hydrogels, it has been very difficult to achieve microvessels with open lumens that can serve as viable replacements for fibrin or collagen [12, 19, 72]. Some success has been achieved within a sprouting angiogenesis microfluidic model, with reports of a dextran-based hydrogel that can support open lumen formation after a 21-day window [72-74]. Additionally, hyaluronic acid-based hydrogels supporting endothelial tubules have been reported, with microscopic evidence of lumens and basement membrane structures, however these culture models were not reported in microfluidic devices [75, 76]. Establishment of a synthetic hydrogel to support perfusable vasculature will further increase the utility of vascularized microphysiological systems in the regulatory space as synthetic hydrogels are highly reproducible, modular, and can serve be tailored to specific cell or tissue applications [20]. This v-CS-ECM hydrogel platform was designed specifically to enable in vitro modeling of the local pericellular microenvironments each cell type in a disease state experiences, as cells can deposit their own ECM and remodel the matrix into a tissue-relevant ECM [27, 29, 30]. In the body, vasculature is subject to fluid flow and mechanical stresses as new vessels are developing and throughout homeostasis [77, 78]. The incorporation of flow to vascularized microphysiological systems further improves the physiological relevance of these model systems, and flow has been shown to play a critical role in aiding in vessel formation and maintenance in vitro [48, 52]. Upon introduction of flow and a pressure drop within a normal physiologic range of capillaries and previously reported microfluidic models [49, 79], we were able to achieve vessels with open lumens in our v-CS-ECM in microfluidic devices (Figures 3 and 4). Of note, our estimated wall shear stress on the hydrogel (0.04 dyne/cm2, Figure S5) is significantly lower than what capillaries experience in vivo (∼40 dyn/cm2) [80], and future studies are needed to investigate how increasing the shear stress to a physiologically relevant range would influence vessel formation. To investigate a potential mechanism to explain why vessels had open lumens when exposed to flow but remained networks in static culture, we examined mechanisms governing extracellular matrix remodeling. The MMP-cleavable crosslinker in v-CS-ECM is susceptible to degradation by MMP-2 and MMP-9, both of which have known associations with vascular remodeling [51, 52]. Throughout the experiments presented in this manuscript, networks that had been exposed to continuous flow had significantly increased MMP-2 levels detected by ELISA in media supernatant collected daily compared to static conditions, and this was observed for both HUVEC-NHLF (Figure 4D) and HUTMVEC-ESC (Figure 6G) networks. While higher concentrations in the pumped case compared to static may arise from enhanced convective transport of MMP-2, similar results have been reported in fibrin, where MMP-2 was found to be upregulated upon exposure to interstitial flow, and vessels were unable to form when exposed to an MMP-2 inhibitor [52]. Future studies can address the regulation of MMP-2 expression at the transcriptomic and tissue levels. Additionally, when we added macrophages into the system, we observed secreted MMP-9 (Figure 6C), which was not detected in HUVEC-NHLF networks without macrophages, even though HUVECs are known to produce some MMP-9 under inflammatory conditions [65]. This can further contribute to the degradation of the v-CS-ECM hydrogel, though high concentrations of macrophages limited network formation, and more work is needed to determine the exact mechanisms governing perfusable vessel formation in our synthetic ECM. An open question is the physical mechanism by which a pressure drop across the tissue compartment influences endothelial function in v-CS-ECM compared to fibrin, as v-CS-ECM has a very tight pore structure with extremely low hydraulic conductivity, such that negligible fluid flows across these gels in the absence of cells, whereas fibrin has a more open pore structure and a measurable hydraulic conductivity that allows interstitial flow rates to be achieved at the pressure drops we use (Tables S1 and S2) [81, 82]. A plausible hypothesis about fluid flow through the v-CS-ECM gels is that cell migration in the gels opens continuous conduits within the first few days. In addition to the obvious morphological changes of the endothelial cells pictured in Figures 4 and 6 and 7, fibroblasts that are not labeled are also migrating. We have previously observed tracks of laminin left by migrating iPSC-derived endothelial cells in similar gels [19], after the cells had moved on to elsewhere in the gel. Such ECM tracks suggest open channels were left behind by the cells after migration through the gel, however further studies looking at ECM remodeling using approaches such as immunofluorescence in this culture format are needed to confirm this hypothesis. Another drawback of current vascularized microphysiological systems is the primary reliance on HUVECs and supporting fibroblasts typically sourced from the lung [2]. While these cell types are easy to obtain and create perfusable microvascular networks, microvascular cells from adult organs display different structural attributes and molecular expression profiles [2, 35]. As more vascularized models have been developed, there are starting to be more tissue-specific endothelial cells in perfusable microvascular models, including mammary microvessels [50], brain microvessels [10, 83], and dermal microvessels [10]. This is the first report to our knowledge of perfusable uterine endothelial cells self-assembled in a microfluidic device (Figure 6), with limited research utilizing uterine-specific endothelial cells [84-86]. We are actively using this uterine bed vascular model for endometrial disease modeling, with the first proof of principle endometriosis lesion experiments shown here (Figure 7) and anticipate this v-CS-ECM will support other tissue-specific endothelial cells, opening avenues for tissue-specific vascularized models. There are a few limitations of this model system, including that the networks must be exposed to flow to become perfusable, unlike fibrin hydrogels, which can limit the throughput of experiments. However, demonstration of partially perfusable self-assembled networks is a significant improvement compared to current synthetic hydrogels for vascularized applications and introduction of flow aids in physiological relevance. Additionally, while we briefly explored a potential biochemical mechanism (Figures 4D and 6G) contributing to open-lumen vessel formation in this paper, future studies are needed to better parse the effects of ECM composition, cellular composition, mechanical cues, device design, and flow profiles on vessel formation in the v-CS-ECM. Finally, for the purpose of modeling endometriosis and the complex hormonal dynamics exhibited throughout the menstrual cycle, we recognize the need to shift to thermoplastic devices as the pre-saturation techniques used to introduce hormones in this manuscript (Figure S14) are not easily amenable to changing hormonal regimes. For the purposes of this work focusing on optimizing the v-CS-ECM for perfusable vessel formation, PDMS devices were used as they are amenable to quick fabrication and design changes. Active efforts are focused on creating thermoplastic alternatives with similar device geometries developed in this foundational work and future work will focus on extended culture timelines mimicking the different hormonal regimes of the menstrual cycle for practical translation into pre-clinical pipelines. The landscape of in vitro models used for endometriosis drug development is still in flux, as different types of therapeutics with new mechanisms of action (e.g., anti-inflammatory) are advancing in pre-clinical pipelines. As with other disease areas, relatively high-throughput static 2D and 3D mono- and co-culture models can provide some information, but as yet are not validated against in vivo clinical trial results. We anticipate that the microvascularized lesion model described here, which can with further development incorporate long-term culture of cyclic hormones and immune cell recruitment and development of fibrosis, may prove essential for evaluating efficacy of drugs targeting inflammatory and fibrotic pathways, and may thus serve as a final step in a pipeline that starts with a high-throughput screen. Furthermore, incorporating patient-specific endometrial cells enables patient stratification studies to identify responders to certain drugs and a deeper exploration of disease biology. Overall, this paper demonstrates a new tool that can be used in vascularized models with room for many future explorations including the combination of organoids and perfusable vasculature for complex MPS. 4 Conclusions In this paper, we report the development of the first synthetic ECM that supports perfusable self-assembled vascular networks in microfluidic devices. We first modified our existing CS-ECM formulation that has been shown to support organoids [28, 29], by decreasing the stiffness and adding YIGSR, a laminin- derived peptide. We empirically screened the number of endothelial cells and supporting fibroblasts to support a robust interconnected endothelial network in static culture conditions before introducing continuous fluid flow. With continuous flow and exposure to a continuous pressure difference across the tissue channel, we achieved vasculature with open lumens in a fully synthetic hydrogel. Additionally, we confirmed the ability of this hydrogel to support the addition of macrophages to endothelial networks and support tissue-specific microvascular endothelial cells, setting a launch point for complex disease modeling. Finally, we demonstrate that this matrix can support the co-culture of vasculature and epithelial organoids using endometriosis lesion modeling as a preliminary validation. Overall, we anticipate this hydrogel should have far reaching impacts on the microfluidic community by creating a reproducible, fully defined matrix to support vascularized tissue models. 5 Experimental Section/Methods 5.1 Preparation of Hydrogel Components 8-arm 20 kDa poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG) macromers functionalized with vinyl sulfone (PEG-VS) were purchased from JenKem Technology (Beijing, China). All peptides were custom synthesized and purified (>95%) by CSBio (Milpitas, CA), CPC Scientific (Sunnyvale, CA), or GenScript (Piscataway, NJ). Peptides used in these studies include: a dithiol crosslinking peptide with an MMP-cleavable substrate (Ac)-GCRDLPRTGGPQGIWGQDRCG-(Amide) (LW); a fibronectin-derived peptide containing the canonical RGD motif as well as the PHSRN synergy site previously described [29], (Ac)-PHSRN-GGG-K(GGGERCG-Ac) GGRGDSPY-(NH2) (PHSRN-K-RGD); a collagen-derived peptide, (Ac)-GGYGGGPGGPPGPPGPPGPPGPPGFOGERGPPGPPGPPGPPGPPGPC-(NH2) (GFOGER); a peptide with affinity for sequestering basement membrane proteins type IV collagen and laminin, (Ac)-GCREISAFLGIPFAEPPMGPRRFLPPEPKKP-(NH2) (Basement Membrane Binder); a peptide with affinity for sequestering cell secreted fibronectin, (Ac)-KKGCREPLQPVYEYMVGV-(Amide) (Fibronectin Binder); and a peptide derived from binding motif of laminin, (Ac)-GCREYIGSR-(Amide) (YIGSR). PEG-VS was dissolved in sterile Ultrapure DNase/RNase-Free Distilled Water (Invitrogen) using a volumetric flask to create a 10% w/v solution in a biosafety cabinet and aliquoted and stored at −80°C until use. All peptides were reconstituted in sterile Ultrapure DNase/RNase-Free Distilled Water (Invitrogen) in a biosafety cabinet at a target concentration of 30 mM for PHSRN-K-RGD, GFOGER, YIGSR, and LW; 15 mM for FN binder; 20 mM for BM binder. To fully dissolve YIGSR a small amount of DMSO (<10% of total volume) was added. To fully dissolve FN binder the pH must be adjusted to a final pH of 5–7 using a concentrated NaOH solution. Peptide solutions were sterile-filtered, aliquoted, and stored at −80°C until use in the gel. All aliquots were used for less than 3 freeze-thaws. Peptide concentrations were measured using Ellman's assay (Sigma 22582) for GFOGER, 205 nm absorbance for PHSRN-K-RGD, LW, BM binder, and FN binder, and 280 nm absorbance for YIGSR. 5.2 Cell Culture GFP-labeled Human umbilical vein endothelial cells (HUVECs) and GFP-labeled human uterine microvascular endothelial cells (HUTMVECs) were purchased from Angio-Proteomie (cAP-0001GFP and cAP-0023GFP). Normal Human Lung Fibroblasts (NHLFs) were purchased from Lonza (CC-2512). Endometrial stromal cells (ESCs) and endometrial epithelial organoids (EEOs) were from our endometrial tissue bank and isolated and expanded using previously published methods [29] under IRB-P0012994. HUVECs were cultured in Vasculife VEGF Endothelial Medium (Lifeline Technologies LL-0003), HUTMVECs were cultured in Vasculife VEGF-Mv Endothelial Medium (Lifeline Technologies LL-005), and fibroblasts were cultured in Fibrolife S2 Fibroblast Medium (Lifeline Technologies LL-0011). ESCs were cultured in DMEM/F12 with 5% charcoal-stripped fetal bovine serum (FBS, Biotechne #S11650), 1% Penstrep (Gibco 15140122), and 1 nM Estradiol (Sigma-Aldrich E8875). EEOs were cultured in Matrigel Growth Factor Reduced, Phenol Red-free (Corning 356231) prior to using in our synthetic hydrogel in a media previously described [29]. All cell types were used between passages 5 and 9. 5.3 Monocyte Isolation Human monocytes were isolated from healthy donors, either isolated from buffy coats obtained from Massachusetts General Hospital or from peripheral blood Leukopaks (StemCell Technologies 200-0092). CD14+ monocytes were isolated from buffy coats as previously described [87, 88]. First, peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) were isolated via density gradient centrifugation with Lymphoprep (STEMCELL 18061). PBMCs were washed with MACs buffer: PBS supplemented with 2% charcoal-stripped FBS (Biotechne #S11650) and 2 mM EDTA (Corning 46-034-CI), and isolated using an EasySep Human CD14 Positive Selection Kit II (STEMCELL 19359) according to the supplier's instructions. Leukopaks were processed similarly without the initial density gradient step. Once isolated, CD14+ cells were cryopreserved at 10 million cells/vial in freezing media (90% charcoal-stripped FBS with 10% DMSO). 5.4 Macrophage Differentiation Cryopreserved CD14+ monocytes were thawed into RPMI 1640 media (Gibco 32404014) supplemented with 10% charcoal-stripped FBS, 1% Pen-Strep (ThermoFisher 15140148), GlutaMAX (ThermoFisher 35050061), then seeded in dishes at a density of 1 million cells per mL in 10 mL of complete media with 50 ng/mL human M-CSF (BioLegend 574804). Cells were incubated at 37°C/5% CO2 for a total of 6 days, with a media change on day 3. To harvest cells for downstream experiments, cells were washed with PBS and incubated in MACs buffer at 4°C for 20 min followed by gentle washing with a p1000 before collection and centrifugation at 300 G for 5 min. Macrophages were stained by incubating with CellTrace Far Red Cell Proliferation Kit (Invitrogen C34572, 1:1000) in a 50:50 solution of MACs buffer and PBS for 20 min at 37°C and washed with 25X volume of MACs buffer before cell counting for downstream experiments. 5.5 Hydrogel Creation Synthetic hydrogels were assembled using PEG weight% and crosslinking ratios denoted throughout the text. In all studies, PHSRN-K-RGD and GFOGER were used at 1.5 mM and BM binder and FN binder were used at 0.5 mM. YIGSR was added to the vascular formulation at a concentration of 0.6 mM. PEG-VS concentrations were 12mM for the 3.0wt.% condition and 14.4 mM for the 3.6wt.% condition. To create the hydrogel, first, PEG-VS macromers were functionalized with the monothiol pendant peptides (PHSRN-K-RGD, GFOGER, BM binder, FN binder, YIGSR) in a buffered solution, with 10% of the volume 10x PBS + 1 mM HEPES, pH 8.2. Briefly, all components were added at appropriate concentrations in sterile conditions, vortexed thoroughly, and allowed to react via a Michael-type addition for 30 min at room temperature. If including cells (all studies except rheology in Figure S2), the desired cells were lifted and pelleted using standard protocols during the 30-min functionalization step. Cells were mixed at the desired concentration for a certain volume of gel (e.g., 18 M HUVECs/mL, 7:1 ratio—for a 40µL gel this is 720,000 HUVECs and 102,857 NHLFs in a pellet) and pelleted using centrifugation (300gx5min) in a microcentrifuge tube. Carefully, all media was removed from the cell pellet after centrifugation, and the pre-functionalized PEG solution was added to the cell pellet at an appropriate volume and mixed via gentle pipetting at least 15 times. Next, quickly the LW crosslinker was added to create a desired thiol-ene crosslinking ratio of 0.43 or 0.52 to the PEG-cell mixture. Again, the gel is thoroughly mixed using pipetting at least 15 times prior to loading the pre-gel solution into the device using a 10µL pipet. Gel batches were typically prepared in 40µL volumes to load 3–4 devices per batch. After loading, devices are placed at 37°C in a humidified incubator for 30 min to allow gelation to occur via a Michael-type addition. Media was added to each device after the 30-min gelation incubation. For experiments including EEOs, the EEOs were grown in Matrigel to an average diameter of approximately 100–150 µm before harvesting in Cell Recovery Solution (Corning 354253) to dissolve the Matrigel. Intact organoids were added at a concentration of 3 EEOs/µL of gel to the endothelial-stromal cell pellet before mixing with the functionalized PEG solution. 5.6 Rheology To measure the bulk mechanical properties of the hydrogel, 50µl of the pre-gel mixture was pipetted into 8 mm silicone molds (0.5 mm thick), which were stuck to slides that had been coated with SigmaCote (Millipore Sigma SL2) and allowed to gel at 37°C. After gelation, hydrogel discs were removed from the silicone molds/ glass slides using a plastic spatula and weighed using a balance to get the pre-swelling mass. The hydrogel disc was then placed in a 12-well plate with 2 mL of PBS. The plate was incubated for 24 h in a 37°C incubator to allow equilibrium swelling to occur prior to rheological testing. After swelling, the hydrogel discs were weighed on a balance to get the post-swelling mass to calculate the mass swelling factor. An Anton Paar rheometer (model MCR302) was used to measure rheological properties. The hydrogel discs were sandwiched between an 8 mm sandblasted parallel plate and sandblasted stage set to 37°C. The shear storage modulus (G’) was measured by performing a time sweep for 180s at 1% strain and 1 rad/s angular frequency. 5.7 Device Fabrication Polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS, Sylgard 184 Silicone Elastomer Kit, Dow) devices were fabricated using a 10:1 ratio of silicone elastomer base to curing agent. Briefly the PDMS mixture is poured in a silanized stiff PDMS negative mold (5:1 ratio of silicone elastomer base to curing agent) and allowed to cure for at least 2 h at 65°C. The PDMS negative molds are created from a silanized positive milled acrylic mold (CAD file available upon request). All devices have a central 1.8 mm wide channel flanked by two media channels (Figure S1). The gel-/media-channel interface features a 0.1 mm phase guide and 8 posts (4 per side), which assist with proper hydrogel loading. Serpentine devices also feature a narrow, serpentine channel (0.3 mm channel width) connecting both media channels. This narrow channel design creates a pressure drop across the gel channel of approximately 32 mm H2O at a flow rate of 1 µL/s, calculated with COMSOL as described below. 1.2 mm holes were punched using biopsy punches at both ends of the gel channel in all devices. In static devices, four 6 mm holes were punched at the ends of both media channels. Once bonded these large punches act as media reservoirs, allowing the device to hold 300 µL of media per device. In serpentine devices, two 1.2 mm holes were punched into the non-serpentine ends of the media channels. Once bonded sterile syringe tips are then inserted into these holes connecting the device to an external peristaltic pump and media reservoir. Before bonding, all PDMS devices were washed sequentially with methanol, isopropanol, distilled water, and methanol, dried with an air hose, then autoclaved. Devices were bonded with the microfluidic channel side facing downwards, leaving only punched areas exposed. Static devices were bonded to sterile 6-well glass bottom plates (Cellvis P06-1.5H-N), while serpentine devices were bonded to sterile standard glass microscope slides. Every device was stored in an oven at 65°C for at least one day prior to use. 5.8 Pumped Device Setup All pump circuit components were sterilized according to the methods outlined in Figure S4C. These components were then assembled inside a biosafety cabinet (Figure S4B), with the media reservoir intentionally left disconnected. Pump tubing was then fed into an Instech P625 peristaltic pump (Instech) and held within the pump by a 3D printed pump cap. 0.5 mL of media was then circulated through the pump circuit, allowing excess media to drain into a waste collection tube. After priming, the inlet and outlet connectors were attached to the media reservoir by the top port and side port, respectively. An Eppendorf protein LoBind tube (Millipore Sigma) with 1 mL of media was also secured into the media reservoir. To connect the serpentine devices, one tube was detached from each pump circuit's syringe tip and affixed to a new, sterile syringe tip. These two syringe tips were then inserted into the pre-punched holes at the top of each device media channel. For the lifetime of each experiment, devices were stored inside PREempt-sterilized 3D printed imaging bases (as shown in the bottom image). Caps from three 15 mL conical tubes were secured into the base and filled with PBS to keep the base chamber humidified, then a sterile universal 96-well plate lid was placed on top of the base to seal the chamber. The full system was then transferred to a standard cell culture incubator, and the pumps were subsequently powered to deliver a constant volumetric flow rate of 1 µL/s. The imaging base was designed to fit inside a Keyence BZ-X710 imaging microscope (Keyence). Pump caps were required to keep the pump tubing from falling out of the pump during extended use of the peristaltic pumps. Both are made from polylactic acid. CAD files for both parts are available upon request. 5.9 COMSOL Modeling of Pressure and Fluid Shear Stress on Hydrogel The pressure difference and shear stress on the hydrogel were numerically simulated using COMSOL Multiphysics version 6.3. Briefly, a steady, laminar, single phase flow assumption was used based on the Reynolds number (∼1.5) in the media channels. The culture media properties used in the simulation were taken from Poon [89], for media containing 5% FBS (density 1002 kg/m3, dynamic viscosity 0.862 mPa.s). The hydrogel-loaded tissue chamber was modeled as a porous medium with the Darcy equations applied. Four cases were studied: 1) simple loop device with fibrin, 2) simple loop device with PEG, 3) serpentine device with fibrin, 4) serpentine device with PEG. Table S1 lists the culture media properties and the Darcy model parameters used in the simulation derived from literature for fibrin [82] and PEG [81] hydrogels. The shear stress at the interface between the hydrogel and media was calculated for each case by multiplying the shear rate reported by the simulation with the dynamic viscosity of the fluid. The flow coming into the media channel from the pump splits into two paths. Most of it flows along the media channel and into the simple loop or serpentine channel and comes back around to the other channel. A minor fraction of the flow goes through the hydrogel from one media channel to another directly. This flow is a direct result of the permeability of the hydrogel. Table S2 lists the results of the simulations for the four cases, and the PEG hydrogel simulations are visualized in Figure S5. 5.10 Pressure Drop Experimental Measurements Vertical column pressure drop measurements (Figure S4A) were taken to verify that the serpentine narrow channel creates a pressure gradient across the hydrogel. For testing, pump circuits were set up identically to a normal experiment and connected to serpentine devices loaded with a cell-free PEG gel. Tubing in the pump circuit was cut immediately before the device inlet and after the device outlet to insert 1/16″ tee union hose barb fittings (T-connector, Cole Parmer). Excess 0.031″ I.D. Tygon tubing was attached to the third barb of the T-connector and was loosely taped to the wall so that the tubing created parallel vertical columns. Media was circulated through the device for 10 min before measuring the media height difference between the inlet and outlet vertical columns. 5.11 Device Maintenance Devices were imaged daily at 4x using a Keyence BZ-X710 microscope in the green channel. Media was changed daily, with 1 mL of media exchanged on the pumped devices and 300µl of media for static devices (150µl per side). Media was collected daily in Nunc 96-well U-bottom plates (Thermo Scientific 268200) and centrifuged at 1000 g x 5 min and then transferred to a new plate for storage at −80°C until downstream ELISA analysis. 5.12 Media Composition for Experiments In HUVEC-NHLF experiments (Figures 2-4), devices were cultured with Vasculife VEGF Endothelial Medium (Lifeline Technologies LL-0003). In experiments containing macrophages (Figure 5), the Hydrocortisone Hemisuccinate concentration in Vasculife was reduced to 500 nM to reduce the effect of cortisol on macrophage activity. In HUTMVEC-ESC experiments without organoids (Figure 6), devices were cultured in Vasculife VEGF-Mv Endothelial Medium (Lifeline Technologies LL-005). In HUTMVEC-ESC experiments with organoids (Figure 7) a 50-50 mixture of VL VEGF-Mv Endothelial Medium (kit FBS was replaced with charcoal-stripped FBS) and Endometrial Epithelial Organoid medium [29] without A8301 and Y-27632 with 10 nM E2 was used for the duration of the experiment. In all experiments, media were changed and collected daily. 5.13 ELISAs Human MMP-2 (R&D Systems DY902) and Human MMP-9 DuoSet (R&D Systems DY911) ELISAs were performed on spent medium. Manufacturer protocols were adapted to be performed in a 384-well plate to minimize the sample volume needed. Standard curves were fit to a 4-parameter logistic curve using MATLAB or GraphPad Prism. Technical duplicates were performed for all samples and standard curves were performed in at least triplicate. MMP-2 values were normalized to total ng of MMP-2 to account for medium volume differences in static and pumped culture settings. 5.14 EEO Emergence Studies EEOs were thawed into Matrigel and expanded as previously reported [29]. Once the EEOs were lumenized with an average diameter greater than 250 µm, the Matrigel droplets were harvested using cold Cell Recovery Solution (Corning 354253). Briefly, Matrigel droplets were collected with wide-bore pipette tips and mixed with Cell Recovery Solution and placed on ice for approximately 20–30 min until the Matrigel was fully dissolved. After dissolving, the solution was centrifuged at 300 g x 5 min to get a cell pellet. Organoids were manually broken into single cells using previously described protocols [29] in a TrypLE (ThermoFisher 12604021) solution containing DNAase (Sigma Aldrich D4527-40KU) with manual pipetting. Single cells were counted and resuspended in a functionalized PEG solution (all components except crosslinker) at a density of 1000 cells/µL of gel. Next, the LW crosslinker was added at the desired concentration and mixed thoroughly before pipetting 3µL droplets in a non-TC treated 96 well plate. The hydrogel droplets were placed in a 37°C incubator for 30 min to allow gelation to occur before adding 150µL of complete EEO medium (including ROCKi). Imaging was performed every day using a Molecular Devices ImageXpress for the course of a week to visualize EEO emergence. Media changes were performed every other day. 5.15 E2 Presoaking PDMS rapidly absorbs hormones, therefore, to mitigate this issue we developed a method to pre-saturate the devices with estradiol (E2) prior to using them in experiments. To do this, devices were fully submerged in a 10 nM E2 solution in PBS for 24 h and then the solution was aspirated, and devices were dried in a 37°C vacuum oven overnight. Controls for this experiment included devices that were not presoaked and devices that were presoaked and did not get media with E2. After presoaking devices (in a solution of 10 nM E2 or PBS without E2) and drying, blank gel without cells was loaded into 2 devices per condition (6 devices total). After gelation, media containing 10 nM E2 or without E2 was added and changed daily for a duration of 6 days. Media was collected each day and stored at −80°C for downstream analysis. After the experiment, media from each condition were analyzed using an estradiol ELISA kit (DRG International EIA2693). The concentration of estradiol in the spent medium was normalized to the 10 nM E2 media to calculate the fraction of E2 that was taken up by PDMS. 5.16 Network Morphology Analysis Devices were imaged at either Day 5 or 7 on a Zeiss LSM 880 confocal microscope with a 10x objective using a 488 laser to image the GFP-labeled endothelial cells. Z-stacks are taken at a least 3 distinct sites per device and export a maximum intensity projection (MIP) for analysis. Image files are processed using REAVER [46], a MATLAB based analysis, to quantify mean network diameter, total network length, network length density, and area fraction. To assess network morphology in devices with organoids as shown in Figure S15, images were analyzed for at least 3 distinct sites per device that did not have an organoid in the field of view. 5.17 Perfusability Quantification Perfusability was assessed by the flow of fluorescent microbeads (Invitrogen FluoSpheres Polystyrene Microspheres, 1.0 µm), which were added to the media reservoir and circulated for at least an hour on the final day of the experiment, with experiments ending between day 7 and day 10. Since the beads do not fully fill the vessels and flow across the vessels, perfusability was quantified per region of the device. If at least half of the vessels in each region of the device contained beads that section of the device was considered perfusable. Quantification was performed by dividing the device per post region and the 2 edges (Figure S7B), with each post region representing 16.6% (1/6) of the total area and the edges together representing 16.6% (1/6) of the device. 5.18 Endometrial Epithelial Organoid Growth Quantification To quantify organoid growth, three organoids in distinct areas of the device were tracked for growth. Day 1 images were used to assess the initial diameter as it is difficult to clearly visualize organoids on Day 0 prior to any network self-assembly. The diameter of the organoids was measured using Fiji for Day 3 and Day 6 images and fold change from Day 1 diameter was quantified. 5.19 Quantification and Statistical Analysis Data are expressed as mean± standard deviation, with individual data replicates shown. Each point represents a single device. Graphs were created and statistical analysis was performed using GraphPad Prism 10. Specific sample sizes are noted on each figure legend. Statistical significance is defined by * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01, *** p < 0.001. Author Contributions L.P and L.G conceived the study. L.G. supervised the study. L.P designed experiments. L.P. and R.O. conducted experiments. L.B. helped design and conduct all experiments with macrophages. A.J. assisted with maintenance on experiments and performed ELISAs. P.R., M.J., and D.T. performed device design and fabrication. L.P. wrote the manuscript. All authors reviewed and provided feedback on the manuscript.

Acknowledgements

This work was funded by National Institutes of Health U01EB029132, National Institutes of Health R01HD114214, a sponsored research agreement with NovoNordisk, Manton Foundation, Fairbairn DAF, and John and Karine Begg Fund. Schematics created in BioRender: Pruett, L. (2026) https://BioRender.com/lfxlwvb. The authors would like to thank Dr. Samantha Holt, Ellen Kan, and Erin Tevonian for their technical expertise and support throughout this project. Conflicts of Interest L.P. and L.G. have filed a patent application (U.S. Application No. 63/892,868) on the vascular synthetic hydrogel. Data Availability Statement The data that support the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.;

Text is read by the "Ask this paper" AI Q&A widget below. Extraction quality varies by source — PMC NXML preserves structure cleanly, OA-HTML may include some navigation residue, and OA-PDF can have broken hyphenation. The publisher copy (via DOI) is the canonical version.

My notes (saved in your browser only)

Ask this paper AI returns verbatim quotes from the full text · source: oa-doi-fallback

Answers must be backed by verbatim quotes from this paper's full text. Hallucinated quotes are dropped automatically; if no verbatim passage answers the question, we say so. How this works

Condition tags

endometriosis

Citation neighborhood (no data yet)

We don't have any in-corpus citations linked to this paper yet. This is a recent paper (2026) — citers typically take a year or two to land, and the OpenAlex reference graph may still be filling in.

Source provenance

europepmc
last seen: 2026-06-04T01:30:01.192114+00:00
pubmed
last seen: 2026-05-16T00:30:04.923869+00:00
unpaywall
last seen: 2026-05-11T08:34:28.763810+00:00
License: CC-BY-4.0 · commercial use OK · attribution required
Courtesy of the U.S. National Library of Medicine