Liddle SD, Pennick V. Interventions for preventing and treating low-back and pelvic pain during pregnancy. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2015;9:CD001139.
Soliday E, Betts D. Treating pain in pregnancy with acupuncture: Observational study results from a free clinic in New Zealand. J Acupunct Meridian Stud. 2018;11(1):25–30.
Betts D, McMullan J, Walker L. The use of maternity acupuncture within a New Zealand public hospital: Integration within an outpatient clinic. N Z Coll Midwives J. 2016;(52):45–49.
Science Direct. Cupping Therapy. Online document at: www.sciencedirect.com/topics/nursing-and-health-professions/cupping-therapy Accessed August 3, 2019.
Address correspondence to:
Debra Betts, PhD, LAc
NICM Health Research Institute
Locked Bag 1797
Western Sydney University
Sydney, Penrith, New South Wales 2751
Australia
Email:
[email protected]
Lactation deficiency/insufficiency (also known as agalactia, hypogalactia, agalactorrhea, and hypoagalactorrhea) is the production of breast milk that does not meet the nutritional needs of the infant fully. Many misconceptions often lead women to believe that they are not producing enough milk, when their milk secretion is actually adequate for the baby's needs.1 True agalactia caused by medical conditions affect 5% of women.2 Such conditions include deficient glandular tissue in the breast; retained placenta; theca lutein cysts; hypothyroidism; hypoprolactemia; hypertension; polycystic ovaries; Sheehan's syndrome; breast surgery; nipple piercing; smoking more than 15 cigarettes per day; and drugs, including oral contraceptives, diuretics, pseudoephedrine, and some herbs. If the baby wakes spontaneously to feed, settles down between most feeds, has at least 6–8 soaked diapers every day, and passes yellow stools at least once per day, these events indicate that the milk supply is usually adequate.
Lack of weight gain for the baby is the clearest indicator of insufficient lactation. After an initial loss of 7% of the birth weight, the baby should return to birthweight by 10 days. Thereafter, the weight gain should be a least 7 oz. (198 g) per week.
Most cases of poor lactation can be helped without medication and the methods include increased frequency of feeds, adequate skin-to-skin contact, optimizing the baby's ability to latch on, breast self-massage, and use of a breast pump. Herbal remedies, such as fenugreek (Trigonella foenum-graecum), ginger (Zingiber officinale), and milk thistle (Silybum marianum), help in many cases. Domperidone at 10–20 mg, 3 times per day, and metoclopramide, at 10 mg, 3 times per day are quite effective and are associated with minimal side-effects.3 Domperidone does not cross the blood–brain barrier and, hence, does not cause central nervous system problems, such as drowsiness, restlessness, fatigue, and depression, which can be associated with the use of metoclopramide. These medications can be used until the baby is weaned from breastfeeding.
Pregnancy and Lactation in Chinese Medicine
In pregnancy, major changes take place in the woman's body, especially in relation to the Directing and Penetrating vessels. These vessels control the menstruation below and the milk formation above. Because of the cessation of menses, there is more Blood available to the mother, and this is diverted to nourish the baby and produce breast milk. This Chinese view—that the more Blood is diverted to the fetus (and the resultant reduced hematocrit value in the mother) the more healthy the fetus will be—is evidenced by higher birth weights and fewer preterm births in babies born to mothers with lower hematocrit levels as shown in a study involving 15,3602 English women of multiple ethnicities.4
The flow of Qi in the Penetrating Vessel is increased, the Qi flows upward to the chest and, given that ST 30 is the entry point of the Penetrating Vessel, there is an increased upward flow of Qi in the Stomach channel, causing morning sickness. A Deficiency of Qi in the Directing vessel can cause Kidney Deficiency, which, in turn, can cause Liver Yin Deficiency (Kidney is the Mother of Liver in the 5 Element system). The Liver Yin Deficiency, in turn, causes Excess Yang in the Liver, which rises and can produce migraine, preeclampsia, and eclampsia.
Milk is transformed from the Blood. Qi is required for this transformation. Qi is also required for expressing milk. If there is insufficient lactation after delivery, it is usually due to insufficient Qi in the Directing and Penetrating Vessels. Here the production of milk is defective. In such cases, there will be general symptoms of fatigue, a sallow complexion, dry skin, poor appetite, a pale tongue, and a choppy pulse—a Deficiency picture.
Emotional factors, such as worry, anger, frustration, and resentment, can cause Stagnation of Liver Qi. Liver influences the breast and nipples, and Stagnant Qi can block the flow of milk. In such cases, there will be pain and hardening of the breasts, hypochondrial and epigastric distension, without general tiredness; the tongue will be red on the sides and the pulse will be wiry. In this situation, the production of milk is normal but the secretion is blocked—an Excess pattern.
Treatment
Ideally, one should differentiate between the two patterns—Blood and Qi Deficiency, which is a Deficiency pattern, and Liver Qi Stagnation, which is an Excess pattern. This is the author's preferred approach. However, for simplicity's sake, here, a group of points are selected that can be used in all cases, keeping in mind those practitioners who might not like differentiation.
One needles CV 17, which is the Influential point of Qi; this helps stimulate the flow of Qi. A transverse insertion toward the breasts is used. Next, ST 18 is stimulated; an attempt is made to produce the De Qi sensation. This facilitates the flow of Qi in the Stomach channel, which controls the breast. SI 1, an empirical point for promoting lactation, is stimulated. In addition BL 20 and ST 36 are stimulated to strengthen the Spleen and Stomach (they work together) to produce more Blood. BL 18, the Back transporting point of the Liver is then stimulated to spread Liver Qi (the nipple is under the control of the Liver channel). Treatment is given daily for 10–15 days.
Auricular Points
These points include Mammary Gland-C, Mammary Gland-E, Spleen-C, Kidney-C, Prolactin, and the Endocrine point.
Chinese Herbs
There are two Chinese herbs of note:
-
(1)
Tong Ru Dan (Penetrating the Breasts Special Pill) for Qi and Blood Deficiency
-
(2)
Xia Ru Yong Quan San (Promoting Lactation Gushing Spring Powder) for Liver Qi Stagnation.
Evidence for Acupuncture
Wang et al. conducted a multicenter, randomized, controlled, and single-blinded trial involving 276 cases of hypolactation (138 treatment and 138 controls) using electroacupuncture at SI 1 in a treatment group and LI 1 in a control group. The markedly effective rate was 97.8% in the treatment group and 24.3% in the control group.5
A pilot study, by Li, involving 27 mothers (9 in a verum-acupuncture group, 6 in a sham-acupuncture group, and 12 in a no-treatment group) showed that, when all other things were equal, the infants in the verum acupuncture group weighed 160.13 g more, on average, than the infants in the sham-acupuncture group.6
In a randomized clinical trial by Esfahani et al., 60 breastfeeding mothers with hypogalactia, 30 were given acupressure and 30 were given general education. Acupressure was found to be more effective than the other method.7
Wei et al. studied the effect of bilateral SI 1 stimulation in 46 cases of lactation insufficiency and compared the results against 46 cases of LI 1 stimulation. The results showed 100% effectiveness in the treatment group (SI 1), compared to 69% in a control group.8
A systematic review, by Chen et al., involving 23 randomized and 3 nonrandomized controlled trials showed that women in auricular acupressure groups lactated earlier than women in control groups and had better lactation outcomes.9
A single blinded randomized study, by He et al., at the Beijing Obstetrical and Gynaecological Hospital, involving 276 cases of postpartum hypolactation, showed that acupuncture at CV 17 could prompt lactation significantly, which was comparable to the Chinese drug Tongu Decocnon.10
Marasco listed 20 studies showing promotion of lactation with acupuncture in an article entitled “Lesser Known & Novel Ideas to Increase Milk Production.”11
Illustrative Case
A 22-year-old woman complained of hypolactation after her first delivery. She was in excellent health apart from breast engorgement. She had a history of periodic migraines, slightly raised tongue margins, and a wiry pulse, all of which pointed to a diagnosis to Liver Qi Stagnation.
The author prefers differentiation of Disharmony patterns in all cases and treats accordingly. This was a clear cut case of Liver Qi Stagnation producing an obstruction to the flow of milk, which is an Excess pattern.
The points used in this case were: SP 4 right and PC 6 left in that order; and ST 30 bilaterally to subdue rebellious Qi in the Penetrating Vessel. In addition, the following points were addressed:
SI 1, an empirical point for lactation failure
CV 17, to move Qi in the chest
ST 18, a local point for the breast
TB 3, to move obstruction of Qi flow in the breast
BL 51, to remove obstruction in the breast
GB 34 and LR 3, to de-Stagnate Liver Qi.
All points were reduced. Treatment was given daily. Improvement was noticed after the third treatment. The patient's milk flow was normal after the seventh treatment.
If the patient had presented with general fatigue, dry skin, a sallow complexion, a low tone of voice, reduced appetite, low resistance to infections, a pale tongue, and a choppy pulse—showing a Deficiency pattern, the points used would have been:
BL 20 + BL 23, CV 4, + ST 36, + SP 6, BL 20 + BL 23 to tonify Qi and Blood
ST 18, a local point for the breast
CV 17, to tonify Qi in the chest
GB 41, to stimulate the breast's connecting channels
SI 1, an Empirical point to promote lactation
LR 8, to nourish Liver Blood.
All points would have been reinforced.